which of the two cars would u pick if u had to choose between the two? the 2006 lexus is350..or the 2007 infiniti g35 sedan and why? my brother is trying to pick up one of thoes cars..but cant seem to make up his mind...so all ur pros and cons would greatly help..thanks

Uh, this forum is a little biased. :D

Here are a couple of links that should help:

IS350 vs. G35 sedan thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=300086)

2007 IS350 vs 2007 G35 thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=269221)

IS350 VS g35coupe????????help thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=272025)

Road&Track:1. IS 350 2. TL Type-S 3. G35 Sport thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=255768)

What car to get: Lexus IS/BMW 335i sedan/Infiniti G35 sedan thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=252629)

Here are some more:

'07 G35 6MT v 07 IS350 thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=236803)

G35driver forum: owners seem a bit bitter about IS350 thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=221801)

New G35 or IS thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=208446)

IS v.G35 v.TL................... thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=183490)

Oct Car & Driver Comparison (0-60 in 5.1 seconds)#1 330, #2 IS 350// Scans pg 6 (with G35) thread (http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=176575)

how about adding the G37 as an option also.

how about adding the G37 as an option also.
OP's asking about the sedan...

I would pick the G35.

1.) Manual Transmission
2.) Larger Interior Space
3.) Real aluminum trim vs. painted plastic.
4.) Better looking IMO.
5.) Newer than the IS.
6.) More of a drivers car.
7.) 4-Wheel Steering.
8.) More mods available.
9.) Better warranty.
10.) Price.

id pick the G35 easily for the same reasons as DrUnBiased.

mainly the G comes in stick, has a bigger interior (the IS feels cramped to me), is better looking, is more of a drivers car, and has price advantages

I was in this dilemma two weeks ago, and ended up with a IS350. I think they are very close competiters and very very hard to decide which one to get. I just like IS's styling a bit more that is why I bought one.

I would pick the G35.

1.) Manual Transmission
2.) Larger Interior Space
3.) Real aluminum trim vs. painted plastic.
4.) Better looking IMO.
5.) Newer than the IS.
6.) More of a drivers car.
7.) 4-Wheel Steering.
8.) More mods available.
9.) Better warranty.
10.) Price.

AWD is another thing that the IS 350 does not.

I would pick the G35.

1.) Manual Transmission
2.) Larger Interior Space
3.) Real aluminum trim vs. painted plastic.
4.) Better looking IMO.
5.) Newer than the IS.
6.) More of a drivers car.
7.) 4-Wheel Steering.
8.) More mods available.
9.) Better warranty.
10.) Price.

Reasons why I chose the IS350:

1) A more refined and practical automatic.
2) I did not need the extra room in the back (solo driver 95% of the time).
3) My wood trim is real wood.
4) Better looking IMO.
5) G35 engine is older. IS350 engine is newer.
6) More of a luxury driver's car. (think of the new GS commercial; just because I can, doesn't mean I should...)
7) RWD is fine for me. Gas mileage is better.
8) I'm quite happy with all the mods I've done to my car. Mods are out there...
9) Warranty is both 48 months, with 10k miles difference. If you lease/drive less than 12k miles a year, there is no difference between the two.
10) Resale is better.

Now, other people may not choose the IS because of my reasons, but I did find the IS a better fit for me than the G35...

I'll choose IS350, simply, because it's big L.
As long as Lexus can keep introducing high end cars like LS600HL, and keep its whole products quality not drop, its prestige will grow up, and its low end products should win automatically.

I don't have a deep affliction for either, I would buy a german aside of those two choices.... however given this specific choice I'd take the "L" for it's overall quality and driving experience. I have never gotten the bad taste out of my mouth from Nissans years of skimping on cheap plastic interiors and the wear and tear always shows on a nissan first and a Lexus last.

I haven't driven either so I can't talk about dynamics but...

I'd pick the IS because:
looks better (completely dependent on buyer)
RWD FTW!
auto with paddle shifters are good enough in this category
relaxed interior-the G's interior (drivers seat) makes me claustrophobic
ELECTROLUMINESCENT GUAGES!!!!
ERGONOMICS ERGONOMICS ERGONOMICS. Everything is where I think it should be in the IS where as the G..."where are the $%$#'n sunroof controls?"

I haven't driven either so I can't talk about dynamics but...

I'd pick the IS because:
looks better (completely dependent on buyer)
RWD FTW!
auto with paddle shifters are good enough in this category
relaxed interior-the G's interior (drivers seat) makes me claustrophobic
ELECTROLUMINESCENT GUAGES!!!!
ERGONOMICS ERGONOMICS ERGONOMICS. Everything is where I think it should be in the IS where as the G..."where are the $%$#'n sunroof controls?"


Looks are subjective so I wont state which I prefer.
G35 also is RWD, or AWD option.
G35 also has paddle shifters with the sports package.
As for claustrophobic interior, I'm only 5'4" and my wife is 5'2" and the IS felt very small and tight for us. Even with my small stature, adjusting the drivers seat to my liking then sitting in the back seat was tighter than I would prefer. I really don't know how taller people can sit in the back of the IS. The G had much more room. I think the IS has the claustrophib interior.

The one thing I think is a major plus for the G35 is the LCD screen comes standard with or without navigation. All G35s also come standard with an Audio and Video AUX input.

This question should be asked on the G35 forums too

ur right...ima go post it on a g35 forum...thanks for the tip..also thanks for all ur inputs guys

I like the Is350 over the G35 sedan. I like the interior touches and design of the Is350 overall. Somehow the G35 sedan reminds me of a Chysler Sebring for some reason:uh:

ur right...ima go post it on a g35 forum...thanks for the tip..also thanks for all ur inputs guys

To get a better average yes you would need to post on both sites, you would combine the responses from both sites since they each will be biased and get a better answer.

To get a better average yes you would need to post on both sites, you would combine the responses from both sites since they each will be biased and get a better answer.

Better yet. Let your brother go and really check out both cars so he can come to his own conclusion. There's nothing better than first-hand exposure. After all, he's the one who's shopping.

by claustrophobic interior I was referring only to the drivers seat. I did not sit in the back of the IS or G.

Neither one are really my cup of tea, but I chose the G35 simply because it's the more attractive, less cramped, and more affordable of the two. Both cars offer similar features, but you definitely get more for less with the G35. Personally, I think the IS250 is incredibly underpowered for its price. For the same price as an IS250, you can get a G35 with more features and much more power (as well as space). IMO, the IS350 is overpriced, which is why I would never own one. Also, because it looks too much like more inexpensive cars as the Corolla & Mitsubishi Lancer. If I'm spending nearly 40k on a luxury car, I don't want it mistaken for a Mitsubishi (yes I know the IS came out first).

Overall, both are great cars, but I could never justify spending the extra money on the IS simply because it's a "Lexus". Everyone knows it's the cheapest Lex you can buy, so the prestige factor really shouldn't be much of a factor at all - at least at this price point.

Better yet. Let your brother go and really check out both cars so he can come to his own conclusion. There's nothing better than first-hand exposure. After all, he's the one who's shopping.

You're right but him having a screen name like LazyAlex I can come to my own conclusions about him going and actually checkin out each car........he just rather get his opinion from a lexus forum whether to get a G35 or a Lexus :rolleyes: go figure......

You're right but him having a screen name like LazyAlex I can come to my own conclusions about him going and actually checkin out each car........he just rather get his opinion from a lexus forum whether to get a G35 or a Lexus :rolleyes: go figure......RLMAO.............

I said in my review in which I really like the G35 sedan, for 32k, it is the best VALUE out there in this segment.
After just driving the IS 350 at the Taste of Lexus, it is obvious why it starts at 3k more and it is the better CAR.

When the G35 price creeps up, its a no brainer, get the IS 350. I am 6"5 240, never had an issue up front in the IS, very comfy. The rear is not good at all, lol.

Neither one are really my cup of tea, but I chose the G35 simply because it's the more attractive, less cramped, and more affordable of the two. Both cars offer similar features, but you definitely get more for less with the G35. Personally, I think the IS250 is incredibly underpowered for its price. For the same price as an IS250, you can get a G35 with more features and much more power (as well as space). IMO, the IS350 is overpriced, which is why I would never own one. Also, because it looks too much like more inexpensive cars as the Corolla & Mitsubishi Lancer. If I'm spending nearly 40k on a luxury car, I don't want it mistaken for a Mitsubishi (yes I know the IS came out first).

Overall, both are great cars, but I could never justify spending the extra money on the IS simply because it's a "Lexus". Everyone knows it's the cheapest Lex you can buy, so the prestige factor really shouldn't be much of a factor at all - at least at this price point.


rotflmao:D:D:D
THe IS looks like a Lancer or Corolla. What are you smoking? Its been said by pretty much all forums, its the best looking in class.

You cannot justify spending money on an IS b/c its the cheapest Lexus but you can on a G35 which is a NISSAN SKYLINE but rebadged here?????

Dude, get real and pass the sweet cheba......

To get a better average yes you would need to post on both sites, you would combine the responses from both sites since they each will be biased and get a better answer.

WHile that makes perfect sense I think our members here are fair enough to give a good car a good chance. Being on dozens of forums, our members are going to be just about as balanced as they come. Some places, you even mention Lexus or another brand and its a flame/bigot fest.

This poll is no landslide, the G35 is a good car and people are voting for it.:thumbup:

rotflmao:D:D:D
THe IS looks like a Lancer or Corolla. What are you smoking? Its been said by pretty much all forums, its the best looking in class.

You cannot justify spending money on an IS b/c its the cheapest Lexus but you can on a G35 which is a NISSAN SKYLINE but rebadged here?????

Dude, get real and pass the sweet cheba......

:boxing:

The rear of the Lancer looks exactly like the IS. I swear, I can't tell you how many times I have mistaken a Lancer for an IS. The Lancer is a $14,000 car. I don't want my $40,000 car looking exactly like a $14,000 econo-car. I don't car how many special "L" badges are on it :)

As far as the G35 being a rebadged Skyline, what does that matter? Both Toyota and Nissan have upscale models in Japan that are not available anywhere else. The Toyota Crown is a fine example of this. Up until a couple of years ago, the same could be said for the Toyota Celsior, Aristo, & Altezza. The point is, the Skyline is still an entry level luxury car in Japan, just like the Toyotas I just mentioned (well, the Crown is higher up on the chain, but you get the idea).

Anyway, the reason for getting an IS over a G35 because of the badge is just a silly reason, IMO. They're both entry level luxury cars. We're not talking LS, 7-series, S-Class territory here where prestige plays more of a factor in the purchasing decision.

^^^ There is no logic or decent reasoning in your posts outside of anti-Lexus. No reason to even respond.

:boxing:

The rear of the Lancer looks exactly like the IS. I swear, I can't tell you how many times I have mistaken a Lancer for an IS. The Lancer is a $14,000 car. I don't want my $40,000 car looking exactly like a $14,000 econo-car. I don't car how many special "L" badges are on it :)

As far as the G35 being a rebadged Skyline, what does that matter? Both Toyota and Nissan have upscale models in Japan that are not available anywhere else. The Toyota Crown is a fine example of this. Up until a couple of years ago, the same could be said for the Toyota Celsior, Aristo, & Altezza. The point is, the Skyline is still an entry level luxury car in Japan, just like the Toyotas I just mentioned (well, the Crown is higher up on the chain, but you get the idea).

Anyway, the reason for getting an IS over a G35 because of the badge is just a silly reason, IMO. They're both entry level luxury cars. We're not talking LS, 7-series, S-Class territory here where prestige plays more of a factor in the purchasing decision.

If you like the car's styling, why do you care if a cheaper car resembles it? Many cars in different classes do look alike. And why do you think Mitsubishi copied IS's taillights design? Because it looks special and good. I believe many IS owners didn't buy IS for prestige, I don't care if IS carries a Mazda badge, if it is exactly the same as the current car except the badges.

Infiniti G35 sedan is definitely an excellent sports sedan, I love it very much. In fact, I was in a dilemma in deciding which one to buy, G or IS. Although I ended up with the IS350, G still gets a lot of my respect, and I just saw one gray 07 or 08 G sedan being lowered with 20" rims and roof spoiler, being driven by a cute girl, I was so happy to see that. I test drove both Sport and Journey and I felt more sportiness and less luxury in G than in IS. I have been a 2003 G35 sedan owner for 5 whole years and I didn't regret a bit buying that car, a true sports sedan with a great value.

Well lazyAlex, here's a friend's recent purchase of an 08 G35 S Sedan.
She didn't like the looks of the IS so that was eliminated easily.

http://www.clublexus.com/forums/showthread.php?t=311088

I think the IS350 and G35 are pretty evenly matched and it's hard to say which is the better car. IS350 is a bit faster and more refined, the G35 is more fun to drive, is more spacious, and offers AWD and a manual tranny.

The IS350 costs $3000 more and my take is that most of that is the badge premium.

both cars have their good and bad. in the end if its dependent on space and price go with the G, if you want raw power and the name plate go lexus.

The Toyota Crown is a fine example of this. Up until a couple of years ago, the same could be said for the Toyota Celsior, Aristo, & Altezza. The point is, the Skyline is still an entry level luxury car in Japan, just like the Toyotas I just mentioned (well, the Crown is higher up on the chain, but you get the idea).

Hate to you tell you this but Skyline isn't THAT expensive of a car in Japan. There are cheaper trim levels in Japan that's not available in the States. The Cedric/Gloria (M) is the contender for the Crown, and has been for the past few decades. The Skyline competitor from Toyota is the Mark-X.

"A Crown, one day", is an old saying in Japan, implying a lot of people desire a Crown but just too expensive.

Some of you guys are going way off on a tangents. Who cares what a car costs and how it's positioned in Japan unless you are in Japan?

You look at a car based on its own merits. I'm always a bit mystified when someone says they are shopping for a car and then ask a forum full of total strangers what they think if they buy this car or that one.

Do your own homework, your own test drives and buy what YOU like. Don't bow to peer pressure.

I chose the IS250 over the G35x.

While the extra 100hp in the G was nice, it wasn't something I'd really be able to utilize very much in every day driving. I thought the styling of the Lexus was much nicer, and the quality of the Lexus interior materials (leather, wood, plastic) was just not even in the same league. My kids would have liked a little more leg room in back, but the IS room was sufficient.

The answer must come from within--which car does the purchaser like better? None of us have to live with your decision every day.

Neither one are really my cup of tea, but I chose the G35 simply because it's the more attractive, less cramped, and more affordable of the two. Both cars offer similar features, but you definitely get more for less with the G35. Personally, I think the IS250 is incredibly underpowered for its price. For the same price as an IS250, you can get a G35 with more features and much more power (as well as space). IMO, the IS350 is overpriced, which is why I would never own one. Also, because it looks too much like more inexpensive cars as the Corolla & Mitsubishi Lancer. If I'm spending nearly 40k on a luxury car, I don't want it mistaken for a Mitsubishi (yes I know the IS came out first).

Overall, both are great cars, but I could never justify spending the extra money on the IS simply because it's a "Lexus". Everyone knows it's the cheapest Lex you can buy, so the prestige factor really shouldn't be much of a factor at all - at least at this price point.

Other than the hard drive, the G35 didn't really offer many more features than the IS (and it didn't offer vented seats, which I love). No one is really going to convince the other, since a car purchase is such a personal decision. For me, it wasn't all about HP--if it was, I'd have bought a Dodge Charger Hemi AWD. Call it "prestige factor" if you like, I just thought the Lexus was nicer. If it was a Toyota, with the same styling, quality of leather, etc. and features, I'd have bought it anyway.

I think the IS350 and G35 are pretty evenly matched and it's hard to say which is the better car. IS350 is a bit faster and more refined, the G35 is more fun to drive, is more spacious, and offers AWD and a manual tranny.

The IS350 costs $3000 more and my take is that most of that is the badge premium.

I wouldn't really view it as a badge premium--it's Infiniti under cutting Lexus to gain market share. They know that Lexus has a better reputation than Infiniti, so if they go toe-to-toe, they are more likely to lose. Same thing Lexus did to the Germans.

I think the Lexus IS350 is an excellent car. But its driving feel isn't what I would consider exciting; all personal preference ofcourse.

Whereas the IS350 feels subtle & tranquil, the G35 sport feels very sporty for its class; more of a driver's car. Wasn't impressed at all with the steering feedback & softness of the suspension in the IS.

It all comes down to what your priorities are. And for me, the G35 is more of my type. Luxurious, yet sporty.

This is the luxury sport segment; I don't understand why Lexus fails to offer a coupe & 6MT version of their IS350:uh: . Now that would be an incredible move by Lexus.

Goodluck with your decision. You can't go wrong with either car :thumbup: