OK Acura fans and haters, C&D has spoken
#77
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by dseag2
Sounds like a fairly unbiased discussion, so as someone who has driven the RL because he now owns one I'd like to offer a few comments:
-I'm not overly concerned about the styling because it's nice to be "understated" once in a while.
-I'll never take the car to the track, but I do enjoy spirited driving, so I'm very happy with this car.
-The interior is a model of ergonomic efficiency, even with the ****-controlled nav system, and it's comfortable. I've always leaned toward more traditional instrumentation, but I like the layout. Materials/lighting are beautiful too.
-I don't care about the size of the car, and I don't equate "big car" with "more expensive". It's usually just me and (occasionally) another passenger. I have an SUV for that.
-Everything from the paint to the leather is top-notch.
I've never driven a 5-Series, but I did own an '01330Ci (considered one of the "marques") and although it was fun, I didn't see what the big deal was. I loved my SC430 and my GS300, but neither were much fun to drive (even after L-tuned). My A6 4.2 was a great car, but the service sucked. My '04 TL was a fun, beautiful car but wasn't as luxurious as the RL. Those cars are my primary frame of reference, and for my purposes, the RL is the best overall package. I realize cars get better each year with the introduction of new technology, so the new GS and new M should be quite interesting.
Just wanted to interject the opinion of someone who has driven the car, so hopefully I haven't offended anyone. I try to make a point not to come into other forums and bash other brands. You never know what you will end up owning.
Sounds like a fairly unbiased discussion, so as someone who has driven the RL because he now owns one I'd like to offer a few comments:
-I'm not overly concerned about the styling because it's nice to be "understated" once in a while.
-I'll never take the car to the track, but I do enjoy spirited driving, so I'm very happy with this car.
-The interior is a model of ergonomic efficiency, even with the ****-controlled nav system, and it's comfortable. I've always leaned toward more traditional instrumentation, but I like the layout. Materials/lighting are beautiful too.
-I don't care about the size of the car, and I don't equate "big car" with "more expensive". It's usually just me and (occasionally) another passenger. I have an SUV for that.
-Everything from the paint to the leather is top-notch.
I've never driven a 5-Series, but I did own an '01330Ci (considered one of the "marques") and although it was fun, I didn't see what the big deal was. I loved my SC430 and my GS300, but neither were much fun to drive (even after L-tuned). My A6 4.2 was a great car, but the service sucked. My '04 TL was a fun, beautiful car but wasn't as luxurious as the RL. Those cars are my primary frame of reference, and for my purposes, the RL is the best overall package. I realize cars get better each year with the introduction of new technology, so the new GS and new M should be quite interesting.
Just wanted to interject the opinion of someone who has driven the car, so hopefully I haven't offended anyone. I try to make a point not to come into other forums and bash other brands. You never know what you will end up owning.
#78
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bitkahuna
Excellent feedback. Folks here comparing the 5 series to the RL don't get it - they're completely different target customers. RL more focused on refined luxury ride with some neat features and 5 series still focused on being a 'drivers' car. But more importantly people aren't looking at the cost. Does anyone really think you can get a 545 for 50K? Dream on - try $60! The 530i is nothing special, even has dinky 16" wheels.
Excellent feedback. Folks here comparing the 5 series to the RL don't get it - they're completely different target customers. RL more focused on refined luxury ride with some neat features and 5 series still focused on being a 'drivers' car. But more importantly people aren't looking at the cost. Does anyone really think you can get a 545 for 50K? Dream on - try $60! The 530i is nothing special, even has dinky 16" wheels.
#80
Originally posted by RON430
Fought my way in to, and out of, the bimmer shop after lunch. 530 comes standard on 17s with 18s a no cost option (at least that is what the salesman said). The one I looked at, no navi but automatic, was 48.3 (looked like a couple of grand off MSRP - not a good sign for 5 series sales) and yes the interior is awful. But I do fully agree, the 5 series shopper won't go look at the RL. But it does sound like a lot of Lexus owners will.
Fought my way in to, and out of, the bimmer shop after lunch. 530 comes standard on 17s with 18s a no cost option (at least that is what the salesman said). The one I looked at, no navi but automatic, was 48.3 (looked like a couple of grand off MSRP - not a good sign for 5 series sales) and yes the interior is awful. But I do fully agree, the 5 series shopper won't go look at the RL. But it does sound like a lot of Lexus owners will.
I haven't seen anything tempting enough to lure me back to German cars... until the new M-B CLS. IMHO, it is one of the most attractive designs to hit the road since the SC300/400. But that one will definitely have to wait a few years.
#81
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by dseag2
You're probably right. When I've car shopped recently my choices have been limited to Lexus, Infiniti and Acura. I did the German thing with an '02 Audi A6 and was so appalled by the service I swore I'd never go German again. That, questionable reliability, and the unfavorable dollar vs. euro exchange, have kept BMW, M-B and Audi out of my consideration set. I don't disagree that BMW is a great driver's car, but most of my time is spent in rush hour traffic so I want something supremely comfortable that is also competent when I need it to be.
I haven't seen anything tempting enough to lure me back to German cars... until the new M-B CLS. IMHO, it is one of the most attractive designs to hit the road since the SC300/400. But that one will definitely have to wait a few years.
You're probably right. When I've car shopped recently my choices have been limited to Lexus, Infiniti and Acura. I did the German thing with an '02 Audi A6 and was so appalled by the service I swore I'd never go German again. That, questionable reliability, and the unfavorable dollar vs. euro exchange, have kept BMW, M-B and Audi out of my consideration set. I don't disagree that BMW is a great driver's car, but most of my time is spent in rush hour traffic so I want something supremely comfortable that is also competent when I need it to be.
I haven't seen anything tempting enough to lure me back to German cars... until the new M-B CLS. IMHO, it is one of the most attractive designs to hit the road since the SC300/400. But that one will definitely have to wait a few years.
#82
This may help explain the owners' satisfaction with the RL...
http://www.forbes.com/lifestyle/vehi..._1213test.html
Hope the link works!
http://www.forbes.com/lifestyle/vehi..._1213test.html
Hope the link works!
#85
Lexus Champion
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by 1SICKLEX
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
I'm pretty happy with the RL redesign, and that graphite color you posted is the best I've seen on the car thus far. You have to admit that Acura continues to push the envelope of USEFUL technology that actually WORKS and it USER-FRIENDLY, hopefully driving Lexus to passionately pursue perfection of their own.
#86
Lexus Test Driver
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: MD
Posts: 1,509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by 1SICKLEX
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
#87
Lexus Fanatic
Originally posted by Incendiary
beautiful DC in the background. What more could you want?
beautiful DC in the background. What more could you want?
#88
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Iceman
You REALLY don't like the new RL, do you? In the years I've known you, I first though you were an Acura hater but then found you're an all-around auto enthusiast (I guess you've always been a fan of the Legend and NSX), but now you're getting awfully harsh on Acura. You've jumped right on the "they don't offer a V8 and no RWD and they build some cars in the States and they had a tranny problem and they sell a car for under $30K so they SUCK" bandwagon!
I'm pretty happy with the RL redesign, and that graphite color you posted is the best I've seen on the car thus far. You have to admit that Acura continues to push the envelope of USEFUL technology that actually WORKS and it USER-FRIENDLY, hopefully driving Lexus to passionately pursue perfection of their own.
You REALLY don't like the new RL, do you? In the years I've known you, I first though you were an Acura hater but then found you're an all-around auto enthusiast (I guess you've always been a fan of the Legend and NSX), but now you're getting awfully harsh on Acura. You've jumped right on the "they don't offer a V8 and no RWD and they build some cars in the States and they had a tranny problem and they sell a car for under $30K so they SUCK" bandwagon!
I'm pretty happy with the RL redesign, and that graphite color you posted is the best I've seen on the car thus far. You have to admit that Acura continues to push the envelope of USEFUL technology that actually WORKS and it USER-FRIENDLY, hopefully driving Lexus to passionately pursue perfection of their own.
Certainly electronics are going to be a bigger part of our automotive experience. Good grief, we have guys here change shocks and destroy the ABS sensors and get warning lights out the kazoo. Modding the RL is certainly not going to be impossible, but it is going to take a while. And I would not want to have problems with that drivetrain or computer. I'll bet you it won't be cheap. Hope everyone else is getting tired of talking about the RL, I know I am.
#89
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
iTrader: (20)
Originally posted by 1SICKLEX
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
I've been more excited looking and reading about grass growing. In the winter.
#90
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here are pics of my RL.
I personally like the look of the car as I think its conservative look is nice. I do feel the TL looks better and the IS (which I traded in) to me looks better than both the TL and RL. What I do know is I'd take the RL's appearance any day over the new GS's exterior but hey, I am more into conservative styling it would seem since I think the LS430 is a great looking car and many say it is bland/ugly.
It is a shame some seem to trash the car without ever having driven it but I guess biased opinions will exist. All I know is the car handles great (reminds me a lot of the IS300 in how it takes turns) and its interior is phenomenal as are all the features it has. Really, to those who think it will drive like some big FWD car...you need to go drive the thing and be proven wrong....or don't. Doesn't matter to me but as a fan of great cras I think this one is pretty damn impressive and will be hard to beat in the all around package area.
My parents own a loaded LS430 which is the most impressive car I have been around and you know what? The RL comes close to it. If the new GS can better the RL as an all around package I will be amazed and very impressed.
Here's hoping Lexus does it since I am a huge Lexus fan and always will be unless they really start to screw up thier cars somehow
I personally like the look of the car as I think its conservative look is nice. I do feel the TL looks better and the IS (which I traded in) to me looks better than both the TL and RL. What I do know is I'd take the RL's appearance any day over the new GS's exterior but hey, I am more into conservative styling it would seem since I think the LS430 is a great looking car and many say it is bland/ugly.
It is a shame some seem to trash the car without ever having driven it but I guess biased opinions will exist. All I know is the car handles great (reminds me a lot of the IS300 in how it takes turns) and its interior is phenomenal as are all the features it has. Really, to those who think it will drive like some big FWD car...you need to go drive the thing and be proven wrong....or don't. Doesn't matter to me but as a fan of great cras I think this one is pretty damn impressive and will be hard to beat in the all around package area.
My parents own a loaded LS430 which is the most impressive car I have been around and you know what? The RL comes close to it. If the new GS can better the RL as an all around package I will be amazed and very impressed.
Here's hoping Lexus does it since I am a huge Lexus fan and always will be unless they really start to screw up thier cars somehow
Last edited by RJML; 12-16-04 at 07:47 PM.