bmw 335i adds 57 whp / 92 tq just from xede piggyback
#16
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (1)
Wow, amazing. Looks like the new 335 is going to take over the bimmer world. Makes me tempted to take the g35 in for massaging...service rep at infiniti told me they can do FI fully warranteed. The guy told me Infiniti knows the g35 is bought by many enthusiasts and they want to keep the relationship, don't want us going to other brands offering way more power. I like that attitude.
#17
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (1)
a flat torque curve is the "ideal" torque curve form for a track which the torque is much more predictable and controllable but most of the power needs to be concentrated towards mid-high which is where you will spend nearly all your time. Its somewhat reverse in the 335 case where much of the torque is in the low rpm. Yes the 335 is nice, has good power but it seems to have breathing problems at high rpms it still can improve a lot more but its a turbo car of course its going to have huge gains vs a N/A car. Personally I dont prefer turbo cars because of the increased maintainence and more that can go wrong, engine will not last as long as I wish
#18
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Let's think about this... for what? $900 you get + 57WHP / +92 TQ
So.. for $15.78 per HP, this is somehow a disappointment?
I see 11hp gains on the IS with the Injen Intake ($22.75 per hp)
I see 9hp gains on the IS with the HKS exhaust ($144.00 per hp)
To get anywhere near the 335i, you are going to need to do some serious wrench turning.
For a tweeker, the 335 is a dream come true, a quick snap in module and you gain nearly 60hp
So.. for $15.78 per HP, this is somehow a disappointment?
I see 11hp gains on the IS with the Injen Intake ($22.75 per hp)
I see 9hp gains on the IS with the HKS exhaust ($144.00 per hp)
To get anywhere near the 335i, you are going to need to do some serious wrench turning.
For a tweeker, the 335 is a dream come true, a quick snap in module and you gain nearly 60hp
#20
#22
Pole Position
Let's think about this... for what? $900 you get + 57WHP / +92 TQ
So.. for $15.78 per HP, this is somehow a disappointment?
I see 11hp gains on the IS with the Injen Intake ($22.75 per hp)
I see 9hp gains on the IS with the HKS exhaust ($144.00 per hp)
To get anywhere near the 335i, you are going to need to do some serious wrench turning.
For a tweeker, the 335 is a dream come true, a quick snap in module and you gain nearly 60hp
So.. for $15.78 per HP, this is somehow a disappointment?
I see 11hp gains on the IS with the Injen Intake ($22.75 per hp)
I see 9hp gains on the IS with the HKS exhaust ($144.00 per hp)
To get anywhere near the 335i, you are going to need to do some serious wrench turning.
For a tweeker, the 335 is a dream come true, a quick snap in module and you gain nearly 60hp
This is all without the complications of a stanadlone piggyback system like the Xede which will necessitate cutting into the ECU Wires. I won't even comment on the robustness of Vishnu stuff...
#23
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Los Angeles/Vancouver
Posts: 6,231
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
some good debate going on here
i think with these ECU hacks, reliability of the engine will be in question and that the service intervals will have to be shorter
probably still a price worth paying for that much of extra performance
i think with these ECU hacks, reliability of the engine will be in question and that the service intervals will have to be shorter
probably still a price worth paying for that much of extra performance
#24
a flat torque curve is the "ideal" torque curve form for a track which the torque is much more predictable and controllable but most of the power needs to be concentrated towards mid-high which is where you will spend nearly all your time. Its somewhat reverse in the 335 case where much of the torque is in the low rpm. Yes the 335 is nice, has good power but it seems to have breathing problems at high rpms it still can improve a lot more but its a turbo car of course its going to have huge gains vs a N/A car. Personally I dont prefer turbo cars because of the increased maintainence and more that can go wrong, engine will not last as long as I wish
And I have over 120,000 miles on it already, and the only maintenance I have is the regular maintenance interval I followed as the factory recommended. Had two other turbo cars before also, no engine problem.
#26
Lexus Test Driver
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: ON
Posts: 1,430
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why are you comparing it against NA vehicles? Again this is a twinturbo 3.0L vehicle. You want comparisons? Let's see, there was another I6 TT car, oh ya...the Supra TT. For $900, you could get rougly 100+WHP gains. Want another example? How about a simple ECUFlash on an EVO IX for $299 netting you these gains:
This is all without the complications of a stanadlone piggyback system like the Xede which will necessitate cutting into the ECU Wires. I won't even comment on the robustness of Vishnu stuff...
This is all without the complications of a stanadlone piggyback system like the Xede which will necessitate cutting into the ECU Wires. I won't even comment on the robustness of Vishnu stuff...
Seriously, who cross shops an Evo or Supra with a 335i? No one. Comparing them is pointless.
Last edited by picus; 12-24-06 at 07:17 PM.
#27
Lexus Champion
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: New Orleans Suburbs
Posts: 1,773
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would compare a Supra to a 335i. I mean you can get an extrmely low milage Supra for the same price as a new 335i. $35k-$40k. I mean there both 2 doors, twin turbo'd, same curb side appell at an automotive event. Sure the Supra is old but its still respected. Now the EVO, 4 doors, stop the comparsion right there.
#29
Lexus Test Driver
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: ON
Posts: 1,430
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would compare a Supra to a 335i. I mean you can get an extrmely low milage Supra for the same price as a new 335i. $35k-$40k. I mean there both 2 doors, twin turbo'd, same curb side appell at an automotive event. Sure the Supra is old but its still respected. Now the EVO, 4 doors, stop the comparsion right there.
Yes, you could make the supra into that, and you could make the 335i into a race car; but in stock for (or close to it), they are very different cars.
I'm just sayin'.
Merry Christmas guys.
#30
Pole Position
If I am not mistaken the supra had a slightly larger turbo than the 335i, no? The 335i is geared towards good daily driving, it's not even in the same realm as the supra. Without a single large turbo conversion, and the awesome lag that goes along with that, it will never be an apples to applies comparison. For what the 335i is, an inline 6 with very small turbos, a 25%+ gain from a xede is more than respectable. Same with the Evo; ever tried to start one of those from a stop in 3rd gear? Under 150lb/ft of torque until almost 3000rpm? It's a different machine, of course you're going to get more gains from a simple ECU reflash. Just because two cars have a turbo doesn't mean they are attempting to serve the same kind of market. Comparing a 335i to a Supra because they're inline 6 turbos is like comparing a Z06 to a GS because they're both NA V8s. Do the Supra and Evo suck? Hell no, for the market they intend to serve they are amazing cars, but they are so far removed from the 335i it's silly.
Seriously, who cross shops an Evo or Supra with a 335i? No one. Comparing them is pointless.
Seriously, who cross shops an Evo or Supra with a 335i? No one. Comparing them is pointless.
Now again, if you understand what an Xede does, it is only natural to compare it against a ECU Flash setup (like the Evo example I illustrated). I think folks here are so mindset on NA setups that numbers like the ones posted look so gawdy, but in truth they are just so-so. Anyhow, I may get a 535i in the coming year to really play with it myself and see how much one can extract from it....we'll see.