Mixman

OK. Here are my sensible choice cars.......AWD, not crazy on gas and not too much money. I am aiming for an S5 but the lease rates are still crazy and the waiting list is still long. Possibly a GS450H but it all depends on their availability, my ability to make a deal and those lease rates too.

Och

iTrader: (3)

I never drove the A5, but its so gorgeous it gives me shivers. Based on the looks alone, I'd take the A5.

carguy101

G37X sedan or coupe?

Mixman

G37 AWD Coupe.

DASHOCKER

iTrader: (2)

Audi S5>Audi A5.

So considering your choices I would go with the G37AWD coupe. Beautiful machine

SilverBull

The Audi is sweet looking car but not fast enough in just the A-form. The S-5 is the only way to go in my opinion. The styling is bad *** though for that ride. Either way get the Audi A5 with those choices.

carguy101

I was assuming that the OP was referring to the upcoming 2009 models. As you said, the G35x sedan will become the G37x sedan. Infiniti is also adding an AWD version of the G37 coupe.

Mixman

Yep they are doing a G37 AWD with 7sp auto tranny. Might not come out till late this year early next. Should be sweet. Whether or not it will come in the sport package or not, I don't know.

mmarshall

Speed apparantly does not seem to be high on Mixman's criteria list. So why spend money on more engine than necessary?

Of the three you named, Mixman, I'd go with the G37 AWD. It is likely to be the most reliable of the three. The GS350AWD may be more plush and comfortable, but, according to Consumer Reports, the GS AWD line does not have the reliability of most other Lexus products.....it would be a more risky buy than the generally reliable Infiniti G-series. The Audi A5 would probably be even less reliable...especially in electronics.

But........here's another suggestion. You seem to appreciate a good AWD system. Check out the Subaru Legacy GT.....a superb AWD system combined with Subaru's better-than-average reliability. The Legacy is a nice car inside and out (you will see that when you look at one), and you can probably get a new one for the price of a used Infiniti, Lexus, or Audi. If you don't need the Legacy GT's power, there's a N/A Legacy version available....it's a good deal slower, but uses regular gas.

LexFather

My thoughts. A5 looks good but no true sunroof and still questionable electronics bug me. Also it will be a CLEAR step slower than the GS and G37.

That brings me to the G37. Looks nice, nice interior, will drive the sportiest of the trio. To me though, it doesn't drive that much sportier than a GS to where you can overlook the tiny trunk/backseat etc.

Which brings me to my pick, the GS. It looks just as swoopy as those 2 coupes. Then you get a backseat and trunk and top notch fit and finish with the Audi. Its speed is on par with the G37. What you will miss is the steering response but its a GS so that should be expected.

mmarshall

Would you pick it with CR's worse-than-average reliability rating (the only Lexus model so rated)?

LexFather

I believe that was for 2006 AWD models only. I know Lexus had their best engineers stop production to find out what the flaws were and they had dealers ship problematic cars back to Japan so they could figure things out.

Looking at our forums, I really haven't seen many/any AWD owners complain about their cars.

Ice350

iTrader: (1)

I'd go with the A5.

mmarshall

OK...you might be ahead of me on this one. I didn't know there was an investigation at Lexus on these cars.

Still, it is surprising. It is essentially the same AWD system that goes on the non-hybrid RX models, which have been in production for years....and that AWD system was perfected a long time ago.

Mixman

The Audi A5 and the G350 both run 0-60 at about 5.8 secs. Everyone thinks the A5 is dead slow, but that is only in comparison to the S5.