Forbes: The Battle To Watch: Volkswagen Vs. Toyota
#16
I remember a lot of people scoffing at the idea of VW seriously challenging Toyota but here we are. I'm rather surprised myself.
#17
Lexus Test Driver
I dont think too many people see this one coming, or at least not this fast. Toyota and Lexus have been launching some pretty boring design, they need a kick in the ares to turn things around.
#18
For a long time Toyota was simply ahead of everyone else in hybrid technology. I don't think that's necessarily the case anymore. Ford uses its own system in the new Fusion and that one outperforms the Camry-h and seems to be making a name for itself. Nissan will begin using its own system starting in 2010.
I remember a lot of people scoffing at the idea of VW seriously challenging Toyota but here we are. I'm rather surprised myself.
I remember a lot of people scoffing at the idea of VW seriously challenging Toyota but here we are. I'm rather surprised myself.
hybrid and future electric power system is the only way to go.
They will taste something bitter soon.
They are too obsessed with conventional internal combustion engine. one day, we will call it an old ,outdated system.
though VW is doing well right now.
However, toyota/lexus do needs to design more sexy looking/fun to drive cars though.
I am glad both honda and toyota are developing hybrid performance car. they might hit our market by 2011.
I like ford, and think this company may still have a chance to claim the top spot in the future. Fiesta is freaking hot. sold more than 50,000 in March in Europe. that's right, 50,000 in a month. It might be as successful as its big brother F-series pickup.
#19
Lexus Champion
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Park Ridge IL
Posts: 2,485
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think VW is taking a wrong direction.
hybrid and future electric power system is the only way to go.
They will taste something bitter soon.
They are too obsessed with conventional internal combustion engine. one day, we will call it an old ,outdated system.
though VW is doing well right now.
However, toyota/lexus do needs to design more sexy looking/fun to drive cars though.
I am glad both honda and toyota are developing hybrid performance car. they might hit our market by 2011.
I like ford, and think this company may still have a chance to claim the top spot in the future. Fiesta is freaking hot. sold more than 50,000 in March in Europe. that's right, 50,000 in a month. It might be as successful as its big brother F-series pickup.
hybrid and future electric power system is the only way to go.
They will taste something bitter soon.
They are too obsessed with conventional internal combustion engine. one day, we will call it an old ,outdated system.
though VW is doing well right now.
However, toyota/lexus do needs to design more sexy looking/fun to drive cars though.
I am glad both honda and toyota are developing hybrid performance car. they might hit our market by 2011.
I like ford, and think this company may still have a chance to claim the top spot in the future. Fiesta is freaking hot. sold more than 50,000 in March in Europe. that's right, 50,000 in a month. It might be as successful as its big brother F-series pickup.
#20
Guest
Posts: n/a
In this case, German "Vanilla" is actually much different from Japanese vanilla.
At the core of Volkswagen's brand identity is Germanic road manners in a solid, German package. Say what you will, but most regular Toyota offerings are boring to drive and immensely reliable. That's Toyota's brand identity, fair or not. The floor would fall out if Toyota started making unreliable cars, or if VW ever tried to sell a car that was as boring to drive as a Toyota, with the reliability of a VW.
As for moving VW "upmarket", the entire push went well beyond the expensive Phaeton and Touareg. Starting at the dawn of the new millennium, The New Bettle, along with the Golf/Bora/Jetta and Passat were the three products that were instrumental to not only keeping VW a relevant player on the global stage, but save it's US operation as well. Pierch wanted only the finest interior materials for these vehicles, and it clearly shows all around. There was real reason why these vehicles were more costly than their competition. More standard safety features, better driving dynamics (standard tiptronic), and best in class interior and exterior build quality. Yes, reliability was another thing altogether, but the Jetta and Passat were (and still are), the benchmarks in their classes. It took the Japanese (Honda, Toyota) until their next product cycles to release something even comparable on the safety front (curtain airbags), let alone the packaging/powertrain front. Even today, they are implementing turbocharged and supercharged power train solutions on inexpensive automobiles, releasing automated dual clutch gear boxes not only on premium vehicles, but on their core product lines. The competition is again taking notice, watch for Direct injection, dual clutch, and turbocharging to be incorporated into mass market offerings from other manufactures during their next product cycles. Of course, there seems to be an obvious price paid on reliability and maintenance costs, but that's the cost of state of the art entry firsts.
Toyota, on the other hand, has finally found something to be proud of with their Hybrid Synergy Drive. Nobody could argue that it isn't a good thing for millions of consumers around the world - it's great, but the problem is, it's boring to drive. Perhaps it's fun on a Lexus model approaching $60K, but in a Camry or Prius, it's boring. Not just the engine, the steering, the suspension, it's all underwhelming. That's why German vanilla tastes different than the Japanese variety.
At the core of Volkswagen's brand identity is Germanic road manners in a solid, German package. Say what you will, but most regular Toyota offerings are boring to drive and immensely reliable. That's Toyota's brand identity, fair or not. The floor would fall out if Toyota started making unreliable cars, or if VW ever tried to sell a car that was as boring to drive as a Toyota, with the reliability of a VW.
As for moving VW "upmarket", the entire push went well beyond the expensive Phaeton and Touareg. Starting at the dawn of the new millennium, The New Bettle, along with the Golf/Bora/Jetta and Passat were the three products that were instrumental to not only keeping VW a relevant player on the global stage, but save it's US operation as well. Pierch wanted only the finest interior materials for these vehicles, and it clearly shows all around. There was real reason why these vehicles were more costly than their competition. More standard safety features, better driving dynamics (standard tiptronic), and best in class interior and exterior build quality. Yes, reliability was another thing altogether, but the Jetta and Passat were (and still are), the benchmarks in their classes. It took the Japanese (Honda, Toyota) until their next product cycles to release something even comparable on the safety front (curtain airbags), let alone the packaging/powertrain front. Even today, they are implementing turbocharged and supercharged power train solutions on inexpensive automobiles, releasing automated dual clutch gear boxes not only on premium vehicles, but on their core product lines. The competition is again taking notice, watch for Direct injection, dual clutch, and turbocharging to be incorporated into mass market offerings from other manufactures during their next product cycles. Of course, there seems to be an obvious price paid on reliability and maintenance costs, but that's the cost of state of the art entry firsts.
Toyota, on the other hand, has finally found something to be proud of with their Hybrid Synergy Drive. Nobody could argue that it isn't a good thing for millions of consumers around the world - it's great, but the problem is, it's boring to drive. Perhaps it's fun on a Lexus model approaching $60K, but in a Camry or Prius, it's boring. Not just the engine, the steering, the suspension, it's all underwhelming. That's why German vanilla tastes different than the Japanese variety.
Also things like the Bugatti Verynon are a thing of the past. Porsche and their CEO stated "no show offs", if it doesn't make money, it won't be built.
Funny but one of the major reasons Porsche went from unprofitable to being where they are today is when Wendeking took over and hired Japanese engineers to show them the Toyota method and how to eliminate waste.
For a long time Toyota was simply ahead of everyone else in hybrid technology. I don't think that's necessarily the case anymore. Ford uses its own system in the new Fusion and that one outperforms the Camry-h and seems to be making a name for itself. Nissan will begin using its own system starting in 2010.
I remember a lot of people scoffing at the idea of VW seriously challenging Toyota but here we are. I'm rather surprised myself.
I remember a lot of people scoffing at the idea of VW seriously challenging Toyota but here we are. I'm rather surprised myself.
As for Nissan we shall see, I don't see Ghosen dumping billions on what is needed here and I'm still not sure he is convinced hybrids are the future. He has stated they are a stop gap.
Lexus continues to lead with hybrid tech as well and the new RX 450 h is amazing to get 30 MPG in a 4500lbs vehicle that is not as aerodynamic as a car. Thats just amazing.
#21
Lexus Test Driver
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: CA
Posts: 1,279
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pierch is an enginering genius no doubt but his idea of Audi vs BMW and VW vs Benz was nuts. Audi at least has somewhat of a chance and has gotten sportier recently so thats been great. VW cannot begin to compete with Benz and needs to stay focused on being "the peoples car". There are way to many great luxury brands for people to truly want a luxury VW. That said I have always been a fan of VW interiors as of late, they are very well built and in the case of the Passat, above the usual Camry/Accord etc.
Also things like the Bugatti Verynon are a thing of the past. Porsche and their CEO stated "no show offs", if it doesn't make money, it won't be built.
Funny but one of the major reasons Porsche went from unprofitable to being where they are today is when Wendeking took over and hired Japanese engineers to show them the Toyota method and how to eliminate waste.
Also things like the Bugatti Verynon are a thing of the past. Porsche and their CEO stated "no show offs", if it doesn't make money, it won't be built.
Funny but one of the major reasons Porsche went from unprofitable to being where they are today is when Wendeking took over and hired Japanese engineers to show them the Toyota method and how to eliminate waste.
#22
Guest
Posts: n/a
^^The Phaeton is a true D class flagship. It is superb and on par with everything else. It just had the wrong badge. The resale value is horrid but that means you can pick up a car built in a glass factory where you can eat off the floor for 35k!!!
I love the Phaeton!
I love the Phaeton!
#24
IMO, VW>Toyota and Audi>Lexus, long run terms VW will win once Audi starts selling in the US.
smh @ Phaeton, what a sexy car, VW should have build this car on A6 platform and put this car against Avalon, Maxima etc.
smh @ Phaeton, what a sexy car, VW should have build this car on A6 platform and put this car against Avalon, Maxima etc.
#25
Lexus Champion
I'm thinking VW is going to be introducing some very nice cars in the near future with Walter de'Silva as the design director.
He's responsible for the Audi Nuvolari Concept, much of the design language in the new Audis, which I think is awesome.
Here's a great article in the NY Times.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/12/au...0design&st=cse
He's responsible for the Audi Nuvolari Concept, much of the design language in the new Audis, which I think is awesome.
Here's a great article in the NY Times.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/12/au...0design&st=cse
#26
Lexus Test Driver
I can see how VW will do very well in the enxt few years. Their new designs are very refreshing, not boring like the new Toyota designs. VW's new free schedule maintenance program should also help buyers who is uneasy about VW's relaibility.
#27
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 7,864
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This may have a little to do with VW's recent boost. Government incentives over in Europe! At least 8 countries in Europe are giving cash to customers who trade in their old cars for new more fuel efficient models.
So this high VW is riding may be an artificial outlook of things to come. This incentive won't last.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/n...ar-market.html
http://www.aboutmyplanet.com/green-n...es-in-germany/
They are getting $3,250 cash to trade in! I'd buy too!
Not working out to well for their governments budgets, lol.....
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/646018d0-2...077b07658.html
My money is still with Toyota.
So this high VW is riding may be an artificial outlook of things to come. This incentive won't last.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/n...ar-market.html
http://www.aboutmyplanet.com/green-n...es-in-germany/
They are getting $3,250 cash to trade in! I'd buy too!
Not working out to well for their governments budgets, lol.....
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/646018d0-2...077b07658.html
My money is still with Toyota.
#28
I'd have to pick Toyota. VW has nicer interiors for sure and while the exterior looks of their overall lineup is nice also, it isn't all that great enough to give them any kind of serious advantage over Toyota.
As for driving dynamics, I don't think it plays too much of a role in the A-to-B vehicle market which Toyota dominates, and which VW needs to capture to overtake them.
To sum it up, I think it would be easier for Toyota to produce better looking cars with better interiors than it would be for VW to match Toyota's reliability. In fact, Toyota's already started on the interior aspect except for the Corolla.
As for driving dynamics, I don't think it plays too much of a role in the A-to-B vehicle market which Toyota dominates, and which VW needs to capture to overtake them.
To sum it up, I think it would be easier for Toyota to produce better looking cars with better interiors than it would be for VW to match Toyota's reliability. In fact, Toyota's already started on the interior aspect except for the Corolla.
#29
Lexus Test Driver
Toyota use to have the advantage over VW with access to cheap labor, but thats not the case anymore. With the cost of living rising in Japan, they are paying as much as the Germans for labor. Both countries are else where to try to save money, the winner of the this race will be the one can can stay afloat finanically.
#30
Lexus Champion
BMW and VW have to offer free maintenance due to the fact that they require special oils for warranty purposes and they cannot be obtained elsewhere - Castrol SLX Professional is exotic and no BP/Castrol jobber has it in quantity.