Jeremy Clarkson speaks out against female hosts for Top Gear
08-30-09, 10:15 PM
#1
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
Jeremy Clarkson speaks out against female hosts for Top Gear
Top Gear chief Jeremy Clarkson is no stranger to controversy when he speaks. In fact, he rather seems to thrive on it, which undoubtedly is a big part of the appeal of the show. Earlier this week, he spouted off again apparently in an attempt to irritate (or bemuse) women everywhere while at the same time alienating his core audience.
While discussing Top Gear at a television conference in Scotland, Clarkson apparently indicated that he didn't think a female presenter would be able to hold her own in the testosterone-infused environment that is the Top Gear studio. According to Clarkson: "I think a girl would be a disaster, seeing the chemistry we have now...you bring a girl in and you start taking the **** out of her, that would look like bullying."
What do you think – is Clarkson right or wrong? Could Top Gear benefit from a female voice, or is it better off as a boys' club?
I say don't mess with the greatest automotive TV show ever. Its perfect just the way it is. The idea of throwing a lady into the mix seems weird and will ruin the dynamic of the three other hosts IMHO.
While discussing Top Gear at a television conference in Scotland, Clarkson apparently indicated that he didn't think a female presenter would be able to hold her own in the testosterone-infused environment that is the Top Gear studio. According to Clarkson: "I think a girl would be a disaster, seeing the chemistry we have now...you bring a girl in and you start taking the **** out of her, that would look like bullying."
What do you think – is Clarkson right or wrong? Could Top Gear benefit from a female voice, or is it better off as a boys' club?
I say don't mess with the greatest automotive TV show ever. Its perfect just the way it is. The idea of throwing a lady into the mix seems weird and will ruin the dynamic of the three other hosts IMHO.
08-30-09, 10:23 PM
#3
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
I think it would be so lame to toss some random tarted up chick into the mix. They have done stupid **** like this on the speed channel in the states and it always seems so lame and contrived
08-30-09, 10:37 PM
#4
A woman in a male-oriented enthusiasts' show will be complicated.
If she's dominant and defensive, she'll be labeled a b;tch.
If she's passive and compliant, she'll be a ditz.
If it was a man in her place, he'd be one of the boys who can say whatever he wants to say, all the while being humorous, amiable, stupid, and understood the whole time. For a woman, humorous means she's unsexy, amiable means she's weak, stupid is stupid, and being understood is impossible...
If she's dominant and defensive, she'll be labeled a b;tch.
If she's passive and compliant, she'll be a ditz.
If it was a man in her place, he'd be one of the boys who can say whatever he wants to say, all the while being humorous, amiable, stupid, and understood the whole time. For a woman, humorous means she's unsexy, amiable means she's weak, stupid is stupid, and being understood is impossible...
08-31-09, 01:58 AM
#5
Top Gear has had a female presenter. From 1997 - 2001 Vikki Butler-Henderson was a regular on the show. She more than held her own and then moved to Channel 5 with her fellow presenters to start Fifth Gear, which she still appears in.
I do agree that putting a female presenter in with the current line up might be difficult but I'm sure that Sabine Schmitz, who drove Clarkson around the Nurburgring in her M5, and who presents the German version of Top Gear could do a decent job.
I do agree that putting a female presenter in with the current line up might be difficult but I'm sure that Sabine Schmitz, who drove Clarkson around the Nurburgring in her M5, and who presents the German version of Top Gear could do a decent job.
Trending Topics
08-31-09, 10:03 AM
#8
A woman in a male-oriented enthusiasts' show will be complicated.
If she's dominant and defensive, she'll be labeled a b;tch.
If she's passive and compliant, she'll be a ditz.
If it was a man in her place, he'd be one of the boys who can say whatever he wants to say, all the while being humorous, amiable, stupid, and understood the whole time. For a woman, humorous means she's unsexy, amiable means she's weak, stupid is stupid, and being understood is impossible...
If she's dominant and defensive, she'll be labeled a b;tch.
If she's passive and compliant, she'll be a ditz.
If it was a man in her place, he'd be one of the boys who can say whatever he wants to say, all the while being humorous, amiable, stupid, and understood the whole time. For a woman, humorous means she's unsexy, amiable means she's weak, stupid is stupid, and being understood is impossible...
WOW!!
Beyond true....
I will try to add more inside info to this "story" from trip I took last spring.
Let me check and see if its "cool" to do so. BRB
08-31-09, 10:05 AM
#9
Lexus Champion
Top Gear has had a female presenter. From 1997 - 2001 Vikki Butler-Henderson was a regular on the show. She more than held her own and then moved to Channel 5 with her fellow presenters to start Fifth Gear, which she still appears in.
I do agree that putting a female presenter in with the current line up might be difficult but I'm sure that Sabine Schmitz, who drove Clarkson around the Nurburgring in her M5, and who presents the German version of Top Gear could do a decent job.
I do agree that putting a female presenter in with the current line up might be difficult but I'm sure that Sabine Schmitz, who drove Clarkson around the Nurburgring in her M5, and who presents the German version of Top Gear could do a decent job.
Or it could just be Fifth gear entirely.
08-31-09, 11:46 AM
#10
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
i actually think she's better than the guys, although overall, the scripting is HORRENDOUS. they actually do good DRIVING and reviews, but the on screen personalities come across as sickly and over the top with lame humor.
08-31-09, 12:14 PM
#11
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
i once saw a broadway play called "defending the caveman", a one man show about how in a modern world of feminists, and guys having to show their 'softer side', that guys are often abandoning their true male nature and that no matter what anyone says, there are fundamental differences in behavior between men and women. overall, i think that's true (not saying one is better than the other!).
anyway, in this funny play he talks about how men and women greet one another. a man will greet a male friend with a smile saying "hey a$$hole how are ya!" a woman will greet a female friend with a smile saying "ooh i love that outfit and your hair!" INSULTS vs. COMPLIMENTS. lol
sure we all know exceptions to this, and Emerald, don't flame me, it's just an observation by someone that is sometimes but not always true. 
anyway, i mention this because on top gear, they flame each other constantly, with jeremy commenting on hammond's height, james may being captain slow, etc.
as has been said you'd have to have a very thick-skinned female host who, to quote what someone said about margaret thatcher, has (metaphorically!) ***** of steel.
anyway, in this funny play he talks about how men and women greet one another. a man will greet a male friend with a smile saying "hey a$$hole how are ya!" a woman will greet a female friend with a smile saying "ooh i love that outfit and your hair!" INSULTS vs. COMPLIMENTS. lol
sure we all know exceptions to this, and Emerald, don't flame me, it's just an observation by someone that is sometimes but not always true. anyway, i mention this because on top gear, they flame each other constantly, with jeremy commenting on hammond's height, james may being captain slow, etc.
as has been said you'd have to have a very thick-skinned female host who, to quote what someone said about margaret thatcher, has (metaphorically!) ***** of steel.
08-31-09, 02:35 PM
#12
Lexus Fanatic
I can't help but think of Lisa Kelly, a young (28 year old), blonde (and good-looking) woman who drives big diesel rigs up and down the slippery ice roads in Northern Alaska delivering loads to oil companies on the North Slope. THAT is a dangerous driving job, if there ever was one......and she holds her own with the male truckers.
Last edited by mmarshall; 08-31-09 at 02:43 PM.
08-31-09, 02:57 PM
#13
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
dave barry comments on why men have trouble with shopping lists written by their wives...
http://jewishworldreview.com/dave/barry.php3
http://jewishworldreview.com/dave/barry.php3
08-31-09, 03:03 PM
#14
I don't watch tv auto shows (or read auto mags) to concern myself with gender or age. If they get people who know how to review a car objectively (and don't talk a lot of bull******), I personally don't care if they are young, old, black, white, male, female, or transvestite.
08-31-09, 03:08 PM
#15
Lexus Fanatic