Earlier Avalon sb considered given OP's criteria, being the better Buick back then.

 

Something tells me the OP's girl isnt wanting a Hyundai XG300/350, Kia Amanti, or Buick. If she wants to stick with Honda Id go TSX over the 99-03 TL's. If she can swing it, the 04+ TL's are really nice.

 

Only 10K.. She will just look for a dude that can fork out $$ to get her a new car

 

yep, the first gen avalons were pretty nice and it'll fit your price range

 

The 1Gens, IMO, are somewhat better than the 2Gen and 3Gen models in build quality. But, by now, some of them are getting pretty old and will likely need a number of parts replaced.....especially parts that wear out with age and weathering instead of miles.

 

Yes, and given the $10K price criteria (regardless of car selected), of course comes the risk of parts replacements and repairs beyond routine maintenance.

 

She'd have to shell out between 12-15k for a TL. Slightly above budget, but not too terrible. You're right about the glass tranny though.

Anything "nice" for 10k is going to be older. I may be wrong, but I think she will also be looking for a certain style vs. just comfort or affordability. If she doesnt mind something a bit on the large side you can find 02+ LS430's for about 12k-15k now. Even with 90k+ miles thats a whole lotta car for a very good price.