Civic Hybrid tests Honda's new strategy
#31
You are putting words into my mouth.
1) I didn't say new hybrids aren't selling new. I just said stated the obvious that people aren't prone to purchasing used cars that are near the new value. What's the relevance to what I wrote?
2) Where did I say batteries aren't recyable?
3) Your 3rd point is true, but doesn't really apply to what I said for two reasons: 1) As you implied, the batteries that go into hybrids are huge in comparison to what goes into the others you mentioned. At least a 50-100X more lithium ion is used. There is no relevance to a comparison of the other devices you list. 2) People don't buy the other items in an effort to help the environment, they do with hybrids. Thus the size of the hybrid battery in combination with ignorant hybrid buyers paying markup solely for the environmental benefit is the reason why I mentioned that.
Overall, hybrids are a good step, but overpriced for what they offer, and not totally environmentally friendly.
1) I didn't say new hybrids aren't selling new. I just said stated the obvious that people aren't prone to purchasing used cars that are near the new value. What's the relevance to what I wrote?
2) Where did I say batteries aren't recyable?
3) Your 3rd point is true, but doesn't really apply to what I said for two reasons: 1) As you implied, the batteries that go into hybrids are huge in comparison to what goes into the others you mentioned. At least a 50-100X more lithium ion is used. There is no relevance to a comparison of the other devices you list. 2) People don't buy the other items in an effort to help the environment, they do with hybrids. Thus the size of the hybrid battery in combination with ignorant hybrid buyers paying markup solely for the environmental benefit is the reason why I mentioned that.
Overall, hybrids are a good step, but overpriced for what they offer, and not totally environmentally friendly.
Take a look at Camry XLE vs Camry Hybrid, those two are closely matched in features, yet the price difference is less than $400
So how is a car that gets better MPG and is quicker overpriced technology?
#32
Rookie
iTrader: (15)
Honda is not necessarily ahead of Mercedes on hydrogen/fuel-cell cars. M-B has been working on fuel-cell A and B-Class models for several years......we just haven't seen them here in the U.S. yet. M-B management continues to stubbornly resist bringing ANY of the A or B-Class models to the U.S.....including the fuel-cells.
I honestly don't get turned on with full electric cars because they take forever to charge. Honda claims that the FCX tank can be refueled in 5 minutes. That's leaps and bounds ahead of most full-electric cars. It seems Honda rather dump the money into their hydrogen cars than hybrids. They're putting out cars like the Insight and CR-Z just for the sake of having a hybrid.
#33
Racer
I guess it all depends on how you view hy. I don't care how many hy Toyota sells.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
#34
I guess it all depends on how you view hy. I don't care how many hy Toyota sells.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
#35
it is just proof that people like hybrids... if you dont, buy something else.
With Toyota selling 700,000 hybrids this year alone (more than complete Subaru brand worldwide), people have recognized what Prius and other hybrids offer.
You are stuck in the stone age... its fine, but dont tell us how it sucks because it doesnt.
With Toyota selling 700,000 hybrids this year alone (more than complete Subaru brand worldwide), people have recognized what Prius and other hybrids offer.
You are stuck in the stone age... its fine, but dont tell us how it sucks because it doesnt.
#36
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 7,864
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I guess it all depends on how you view hy. I don't care how many hy Toyota sells.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
It's like saying why pay $6K more to buy a Camry over a Yaris, just get the Yaris and call it a day.
And since you don't own cars for more than 3-4 years, you're a very different demographic when it comes to economics. This practice is very expensive. A majority of people base their car purchase economics on owning the car for much longer, going 100-200K+. This is also where buying a Prius makes more sense. Many Prius owners drive much more than average, inflating the gas savings.
#37
Lexus Champion
#38
Racer
it is just proof that people like hybrids... if you dont, buy something else.
With Toyota selling 700,000 hybrids this year alone (more than complete Subaru brand worldwide), people have recognized what Prius and other hybrids offer.
You are stuck in the stone age... its fine, but dont tell us how it sucks because it doesnt.
With Toyota selling 700,000 hybrids this year alone (more than complete Subaru brand worldwide), people have recognized what Prius and other hybrids offer.
You are stuck in the stone age... its fine, but dont tell us how it sucks because it doesnt.
I never said hybrids sucks, I just don't see the point in buying a 4 cylinder hybrid at a premium unless it offers something very special.
-J-P-L- understand what i'm saying. I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so a 4 cylinder hybrid is useless to me.
#39
Lexus Fanatic
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 7,864
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No need to get personal.
I never said hybrids sucks, I just don't see the point in buying a 4 cylinder hybrid at a premium unless it offers something very special.
-J-P-L- understand what i'm saying. I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so a 4 cylinder hybrid is useless to me.
I never said hybrids sucks, I just don't see the point in buying a 4 cylinder hybrid at a premium unless it offers something very special.
-J-P-L- understand what i'm saying. I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so a 4 cylinder hybrid is useless to me.
Also, you don't have to convince me of economics, I drive a Yaris for reasons that you mention. It's all based on individual desires though.
Last edited by -J-P-L-; 07-15-11 at 05:33 AM.
#40
Lexus Champion
I guess it all depends on how you view hy. I don't care how many hy Toyota sells.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
I can see purchasing a hy for more power but never a 4 cylinder hy to save money when it's at a premium. Save the extra 4k - 6k and purchase a 4 cylinder Yaris or Civic and call it a day. I guess it's something special about own a Prius since it's such a hit here. But I'll pass.
I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so I see no point.
Why buy a LS -- why not buy a smaller, cheaper, more efficient Avalon?
Why buy a GS 350 -- why not buy a cheaper, more efficient 4-cyl Camry? We don't even need to ask about the GS 460.
Why buy an IS 250 or IS 350 -- why not buy a cheaper, much more efficient Corolla?
Why buy an RX 350 -- why not buy a cheaper, more efficient 4-cyl Venza? Actually, there is an even better option. Why not consider a 4-cyl RAV4 with the optional 3rd row? It is cheaper, more efficient, yet STILL offers more seating positions! Wow!
Why buy an ES 350 -- why not buy its cheaper, more efficient fraternal twin, the Camry? But then, why buy the V6 Camry when the 4-cyl is the same car, but more efficient and cheaper?
Oh wait, what then is the use of the Lexus brand? You could get a cheaper, more efficient (and not necessarily smaller) Toyota?
#41
No need to get personal.
I never said hybrids sucks, I just don't see the point in buying a 4 cylinder hybrid at a premium unless it offers something very special.
-J-P-L- understand what i'm saying. I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so a 4 cylinder hybrid is useless to me.
I never said hybrids sucks, I just don't see the point in buying a 4 cylinder hybrid at a premium unless it offers something very special.
-J-P-L- understand what i'm saying. I don't keep cars over 3 to 4 years so a 4 cylinder hybrid is useless to me.
4cly hybrid does offer something special.... in Prius, you get novelty and luxury compared to traditional 4clys, in Camry Hybrid you get almost v6 speed, but with 36 mpg averages.
In GS450h again, you get 25mpg average car that is faster than V8 in some cases, let alone V6.
4 million people are not stupid for buying hybrid vehicles. People in general are not dumb. There is a lot of hype of Volt and yet they manage only 500 sales per month.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
GFerg
Car Chat
20
11-30-06 06:03 AM
LexFather
Car Chat
12
04-11-05 02:10 PM