Why Toyota constantly improving the Prius' fuel economy is a fool's errand
#17
Lexus Test Driver
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Maryland
Posts: 1,243
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd always wanted a diesel. The X5 diesel with the $3500 EcoCredit was literally a no-brainer.
#18
Lexus Champion
#19
executive matchup
LULZ! (oh boy here we go! )
Our X5 35d was CHEAPER than a comparably equipped 35i.
So it paid for itself as soon as I drove it out of the dealership, on top of the fact that my wife and I both liked how it drove better than the 35i. It's tough to argue against 420 ft-lbs of torque AND better fuel economy, AND a lower price!
Okay that was enabled by BMW marketing/sales support via incentives. How bout a different example.
Compare a BMW 328i to a 328d.
The 328d costs $1300 more than the 328i (same levels of equipment) but has annual fuel savings of $500 vs the 328i, and thus the break even is less than 3 years and under 50,000 miles. Not many many many years, and many hundreds of thousands of miles. THREE years.
This is why I've been a huge fan of diesels for so long, and am so enthusiastic about seeing a lot more of them here in the U.S. Their cost delta over a naturally aspirated or turbo petrol powertrain is typically less than half of what a hybrid costs, yet there's still a huge jump in fuel economy, and the break even is far sooner. On top of all that, the torque is awesome and they drive wonderfully. The figures above are off of fueleconomy.gov (run by the U.S. EPA) and doesn't even take into account the fact that EPA methodology tends to overestimate petrol engine economy while underestimating diesel engine economy.
If Toyota offered a turbodiesel 4-cylinder in the Camry for $2k more than the regular model that would get their highway mileage well into the 40 mpg range as the 328d does with a break even at 3 years, I guarantee you that they'd have bought it. They do mostly highway driving, where diesels especially shine. They skipped the Hybrid as it would never have paid off.
Our X5 35d was CHEAPER than a comparably equipped 35i.
So it paid for itself as soon as I drove it out of the dealership, on top of the fact that my wife and I both liked how it drove better than the 35i. It's tough to argue against 420 ft-lbs of torque AND better fuel economy, AND a lower price!
Okay that was enabled by BMW marketing/sales support via incentives. How bout a different example.
Compare a BMW 328i to a 328d.
The 328d costs $1300 more than the 328i (same levels of equipment) but has annual fuel savings of $500 vs the 328i, and thus the break even is less than 3 years and under 50,000 miles. Not many many many years, and many hundreds of thousands of miles. THREE years.
This is why I've been a huge fan of diesels for so long, and am so enthusiastic about seeing a lot more of them here in the U.S. Their cost delta over a naturally aspirated or turbo petrol powertrain is typically less than half of what a hybrid costs, yet there's still a huge jump in fuel economy, and the break even is far sooner. On top of all that, the torque is awesome and they drive wonderfully. The figures above are off of fueleconomy.gov (run by the U.S. EPA) and doesn't even take into account the fact that EPA methodology tends to overestimate petrol engine economy while underestimating diesel engine economy.
If Toyota offered a turbodiesel 4-cylinder in the Camry for $2k more than the regular model that would get their highway mileage well into the 40 mpg range as the 328d does with a break even at 3 years, I guarantee you that they'd have bought it. They do mostly highway driving, where diesels especially shine. They skipped the Hybrid as it would never have paid off.
good for you on your decision, but financial payback doesn't enter my equation when i buy a car...i drive aprox 3,000 km a year, so it wouldn't matter whether my car was a hybrid, diesel or something in between, it would not make sense to buy a car if i used your cost/benefit analysis. i bought my GS450h for the latest in technology (at the time) and luxury, better fuel mileage, and reliability. i have zero complaints to date.
#20
Lexus Test Driver
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Maryland
Posts: 1,243
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Hoovey689
Car Chat
21
01-18-14 03:23 PM
Hoovey689
Car Chat
1
10-26-12 09:39 PM