3 pedals vs 2 pedals
#17
all the engines go through a lot harsher "break in" at manufacturers when they are built, i wouldn't worry too much about brake in these days
in terms of efficiency and ultimate performance, auto is ahead of manual since years ago. but in terms of fun? manual any day
in terms of efficiency and ultimate performance, auto is ahead of manual since years ago. but in terms of fun? manual any day
#18
how about that, a quantum physics lesson in a thread about clutch pedals lol...
#20
#21
#23
The bottom line is that any "debate" is purely an academic exercise. Car companies are not bringing back the manual transmissions--some exotic sports cars come with what is essentially an automatic with paddle shifters (which I'm assuming do not have to be used). The ship has sailed on the MT. I don't think it will ever be completely dead, but it will forever be a rarity going forward.
#24
The ship has sailed is about the right descriptor. I was once a 3-pedal devotee, but while we all like to romanticize the idea of doing a little extra work to have more control of the vehicle, when it becomes arbitrary and no longer the efficient mode of operating the car it's an exercise in futility.
That said, I'm not opposed at all to driving small, lightweight economy cars where there are real cost savings and efficiency benefits to a manual gearbox, or on the increasingly slim amount of performance vehicles that actually offer one. But forcing yourself into a manual gearbox on a commuter car for the sake of perceived "driving fun" with no speed or fuel economy benefits (like the old IS250 manual) I find completely pointless. It's like making yourself work harder for less.
I'd drive a rental in a manual if the roads in where I am traveling are favorable to it (long windy coastlines), but I'd never own one again, unless I can afford to fund a 3 car garage.
That said, I'm not opposed at all to driving small, lightweight economy cars where there are real cost savings and efficiency benefits to a manual gearbox, or on the increasingly slim amount of performance vehicles that actually offer one. But forcing yourself into a manual gearbox on a commuter car for the sake of perceived "driving fun" with no speed or fuel economy benefits (like the old IS250 manual) I find completely pointless. It's like making yourself work harder for less.
I'd drive a rental in a manual if the roads in where I am traveling are favorable to it (long windy coastlines), but I'd never own one again, unless I can afford to fund a 3 car garage.
Last edited by svelt; 09-11-16 at 10:07 AM.
#25
i understand what you're trying to say but this is actually incorrect. when flowing through a wire electrons in fact travel quite slowly, less than a millimeter per second in most cases. the wire however is full of electrons so an input at one end can almost immediately be received at the other, much like if a hose is full of water and someone turns the water on. electrons "do" technically have a measurable mass, therefore by definition it is impossible for them to travel at true light speed.
how about that, a quantum physics lesson in a thread about clutch pedals lol...
how about that, a quantum physics lesson in a thread about clutch pedals lol...
The majority of automatic transmissions, especially the newest electronically-controlled 8-, 9- and 10-speed units are these types of transmissions with planetary gearsets.
#26
With all due respect, this does not explain why manually shifting a normal automatic transmission (i.e. a transmission based upon a torque converter and planetary gearset(s) or "slushbox") takes so long to respond, even if they do come with paddle shifters or some other type of manual-shift gate or mechanism: manually request a gear change via a paddle or the manual gate, and it takes a measurable (slow) amount of time before the transmission responds.
The majority of automatic transmissions, especially the newest electronically-controlled 8-, 9- and 10-speed units are these types of transmissions with planetary gearsets.
The majority of automatic transmissions, especially the newest electronically-controlled 8-, 9- and 10-speed units are these types of transmissions with planetary gearsets.
#28
To to people who would be interested in a manual, that total control and knowing that the car running depends on you making proper shifts is part of the experience.
its like skydiving in tandem vs on your own. Yeah, in tandem you pull the rip cord but if you don't pull it, the guy will. Your life is not really ever in your own hands. That experience is important to some people.
#29
its like skydiving in tandem vs on your own. Yeah, in tandem you pull the rip cord but if you don't pull it, the guy will. Your life is not really ever in your own hands. That experience is important to some people.