Mercedes-Benz to drop V6 engines in favor of new inline-sixes
#16
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Still for the more "average" man with less deep pocket books, I swear up and down that an inline six is smoother than a V8, at least in all the cars I've driven(2JZ Toyota/Lexus products, Jaguar XJ sedans with the inline six), cars with those two engines felt smoother than any V8 I've driven. Maybe not as much personality as some other luxury V8's(love the sound/feel of Audi's old 4.2 V8), but definitely the kings of smooth.
#17
Lexus Fanatic
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I've heard that before and will take your word on it, as I haven't had any significant seat time in a V12 car, either Italian exotic or German luxury. Its just when you say V12 I think Ferrari or Lamborghini, not Mercedes-Benz. I also kind of wonder if that the V12 Benz is so refined due to it being stuffed with 500lbs of sound insulation and highly sophisticated(ie $$$) motor mounts. Those V12 Benz cars, with their twin turbos make similar power to naturally aspirated V12 engines from Italy.
Still for the more "average" man with less deep pocket books, I swear up and down that an inline six is smoother than a V8, at least in all the cars I've driven(2JZ Toyota/Lexus products, Jaguar XJ sedans with the inline six), cars with those two engines felt smoother than any V8 I've driven. Maybe not as much personality as some other luxury V8's(love the sound/feel of Audi's old 4.2 V8), but definitely the kings of smooth.
Still for the more "average" man with less deep pocket books, I swear up and down that an inline six is smoother than a V8, at least in all the cars I've driven(2JZ Toyota/Lexus products, Jaguar XJ sedans with the inline six), cars with those two engines felt smoother than any V8 I've driven. Maybe not as much personality as some other luxury V8's(love the sound/feel of Audi's old 4.2 V8), but definitely the kings of smooth.
#18
Lexus Test Driver
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I remember the IS300's inline six. It indeed was a very impressive motor. However, my friend's 1990's ES300 had what I assume was a regular 3.0 V6 in it, and it was far smoother. Maybe it was the added sound-deadening and lack of any exhaust note that gave the impression. You really could not hear or feel anything at all if wound up to redline. Both good motors. I'm a sucker for stealthy power, where a vehicle builds up rapid speed while surprising passengers due to lack of noise or vibration.
#19
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
In-line sixes can vary quite a bit in smoothness. The old Chrysler Slant Six, for instance, that I learned to drive on, decades ago, was a durable as a tank (it was commonly used in taxis), but was somewhat lacking in the NVH category.....competitors from Ford, GM, and AMC generally ran a little smoother. The Toyota/Lexus 3.0L straight-six you speak of (I has one in my IS300), yes, was smooth as butter....but it guzzled gas like a V8, with (in the non-turbo version) only a little over 200 HP to show for it. At the time it was produced in the IS300, its EPA ratings, if my memory is correct, were only 23 highway, 17 city.
Of course the JZ family of inline six engines were a product of Japan's "bubble economy" of the late 1980's. Fuel economy was not a priority and they were designed to have two turbos strapped on to them that made about 100 more hp than the non-turbo motors. For "reasons" the US Lexus division got the shaft on turbocharged JZ engines that were found in identical Japanese market cars.
#20
Lexus Test Driver
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I remember the IS300's inline six. It indeed was a very impressive motor. However, my friend's 1990's ES300 had what I assume was a regular 3.0 V6 in it, and it was far smoother. Maybe it was the added sound-deadening and lack of any exhaust note that gave the impression. You really could not hear or feel anything at all if wound up to redline. Both good motors. I'm a sucker for stealthy power, where a vehicle builds up rapid speed while surprising passengers due to lack of noise or vibration.
Your confusing sound with smoothness.
The IS was a sport model at that time therefore engine noise was most likely on purpose. In addition, it was never developed to be a Lexus.
Smoothness refers to how the power is delivered. Inline 6 engines have very linear power delivery and there is not as much stress on the engine therefore it doesn't create as much vibration like a similar V6, which also translates to smoothness.
I recommend you drive a inline 6 GS300 and compare it to the ES, world of difference.
The IS was a sport model at that time therefore engine noise was most likely on purpose. In addition, it was never developed to be a Lexus.
Smoothness refers to how the power is delivered. Inline 6 engines have very linear power delivery and there is not as much stress on the engine therefore it doesn't create as much vibration like a similar V6, which also translates to smoothness.
I recommend you drive a inline 6 GS300 and compare it to the ES, world of difference.
#21
Lexus Test Driver
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Your confusing sound with smoothness.
The IS was a sport model at that time therefore engine noise was most likely on purpose. In addition, it was never developed to be a Lexus.
Smoothness refers to how the power is delivered. Inline 6 engines have very linear power delivery and there is not as much stress on the engine therefore it doesn't create as much vibration like a similar V6, which also translates to smoothness.
I recommend you drive a inline 6 GS300 and compare it to the ES, world of difference.
The IS was a sport model at that time therefore engine noise was most likely on purpose. In addition, it was never developed to be a Lexus.
Smoothness refers to how the power is delivered. Inline 6 engines have very linear power delivery and there is not as much stress on the engine therefore it doesn't create as much vibration like a similar V6, which also translates to smoothness.
I recommend you drive a inline 6 GS300 and compare it to the ES, world of difference.
#22
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
In-line sixes can vary quite a bit in smoothness. The old Chrysler Slant Six, for instance, that I learned to drive on, decades ago, was a durable as a tank (it was commonly used in taxis), but was somewhat lacking in the NVH category.....competitors from Ford, GM, and AMC generally ran a little smoother. The Toyota/Lexus 3.0L straight-six you speak of (I has one in my IS300), yes, was smooth as butter....
#23
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I have driven brand new IS and GS 3.0 in-line sixes, and onwed many V6's.
The IS and GS in-line sixes has straighter inlet ports for superior low RPM breathing, and hence bags of bottom end torque, and a more linear torque curve as some have mentioned.
My Mercedes used the old 90 degree V6 that shared casting dies with 90 degree V8 blocks, and the breathing ability was poor - hence a total lack of bottom end torque!
Benz's 90 degree V6 was rough too.
However, I thought the IS and GS in-line sixes were absolutely no match for the smoothness of Mazda 929, 626, and numerous Toyota/Lexus and Honda 60 degree V6's.
The BMW in-line six is actually smoother than the IS/GS in-line six, probably because TMC did not bother to develop their in-line sixes any further, but the BMW in-line sixes were still no match for Japanese 60 degree V6's for smoothness and quietness...
The IS and GS in-line sixes has straighter inlet ports for superior low RPM breathing, and hence bags of bottom end torque, and a more linear torque curve as some have mentioned.
My Mercedes used the old 90 degree V6 that shared casting dies with 90 degree V8 blocks, and the breathing ability was poor - hence a total lack of bottom end torque!
Benz's 90 degree V6 was rough too.
However, I thought the IS and GS in-line sixes were absolutely no match for the smoothness of Mazda 929, 626, and numerous Toyota/Lexus and Honda 60 degree V6's.
The BMW in-line six is actually smoother than the IS/GS in-line six, probably because TMC did not bother to develop their in-line sixes any further, but the BMW in-line sixes were still no match for Japanese 60 degree V6's for smoothness and quietness...
#24
Lexus Fanatic
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
One very interesting exception to the packaging issue, however (though it was a rather mediocre car) was the Suzuki Verona sedan, which was actually a rebadged version of the Korean-designed Daewoo Magnus. It was the only transverse-mounted/FWD application of an in-line six I can ever remember seeing in the American market. Somehow, with small cylinders and only 2.5L of displacement, they managed to make it fit into the mid-sized Verona transversely and hook to up to the transmission and final-drive unit. To be honest, I don't really remember how smoothly or roughly it ran, though I do remember that, like the 1Gen Kia Amanti, The Verona's road manners left a little to be desired....it was a Ho-Hum driving experience at best.
![](https://file.kbb.com/kbb/vehicleimage/housenew/640x480/2004/2004-suzuki-verona-misc_scverint0498.jpg)
Last edited by mmarshall; 01-24-18 at 03:48 PM.
#25
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Late 90's/early 2000's Jeep 4.0 inline six comes to mind. Not terribly refined, kind of noisy, thrashy, but they made great torque, very reliable and long lasting. Reason for its greatness is that the Jeep inline six is actually an AMC design, not a Chrysler design IMO, the engine dates back to when AMC owned Jeep, Chrysler bought them, this motor was a carryover for many many years.
#26
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
As for MB, this makes sense. Especially as they too are pushing more and more 4 cylinder motors.
#27
Lexus Fanatic
![Default](https://www.clublexus.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Outside of Lexus and BMW, there have actually been very few of them in modern American-market vehicles, period....maybe one or two of them from Mercedes. With the push for downsizing in the late 1970s, underhood packaging became an issue, particularly with FWD.
One very interesting exception to the packaging issue, however (though it was a rather mediocre car) was the Suzuki Verona sedan, which was actually a rebadged version of the Korean-designed Daewoo Magnus. It was the only transverse-mounted/FWD application of an in-line six I can ever remember seeing in the American market. Somehow, with small cylinders and only 2.5L of displacement, they managed to make it fit into the mid-sized Verona transversely and hook to up to the transmission and final-drive unit. To be honest, I don't really remember how smoothly or roughly it ran, though I do remember that, like the 1Gen Kia Amanti, The Verona's road manners left a little to be desired....it was a Ho-Hum driving experience at best.
![](https://file.kbb.com/kbb/vehicleimage/housenew/640x480/2004/2004-suzuki-verona-misc_scverint0498.jpg)
One very interesting exception to the packaging issue, however (though it was a rather mediocre car) was the Suzuki Verona sedan, which was actually a rebadged version of the Korean-designed Daewoo Magnus. It was the only transverse-mounted/FWD application of an in-line six I can ever remember seeing in the American market. Somehow, with small cylinders and only 2.5L of displacement, they managed to make it fit into the mid-sized Verona transversely and hook to up to the transmission and final-drive unit. To be honest, I don't really remember how smoothly or roughly it ran, though I do remember that, like the 1Gen Kia Amanti, The Verona's road manners left a little to be desired....it was a Ho-Hum driving experience at best.
![](https://file.kbb.com/kbb/vehicleimage/housenew/640x480/2004/2004-suzuki-verona-misc_scverint0498.jpg)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volvo_SI6_engine
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rotaryrock
Car Chat
4
09-04-07 04:00 PM