Car Chat General discussion about Lexus, other auto manufacturers and automotive news.

salt damage / beet juice

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 01-24-18 | 07:42 AM
  #16  
mmarshall's Avatar
mmarshall
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 91,623
Likes: 89
From: Virginia/D.C. suburbs
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
i don't think humidity is a factor. as for heat and direct sun, that's what a garage is for.
Yes, humidity is a factor...but more so at high temperatures. Lower temperatures tend to lower the rate of the oxidation process in metal. That is why aircraft and vehicles stay relatively rust-free even in the high temperatures of the Arizona desert...the extremely low humidity simply prevents most of the oxidation process. If you doubt my word, ask a chemist or metallurgy engineer. We also see that in naval aircraft aboard ships at sea or on land bases on the coast....special processes in the construction designed to protect against intense salt-effects.
Old 01-24-18 | 07:45 AM
  #17  
bitkahuna's Avatar
bitkahuna
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
 
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 75,499
Likes: 2,559
From: Present
Default

it's pretty simple... you don't see rusty cars in florida.
Old 01-24-18 | 07:45 AM
  #18  
SW17LS's Avatar
SW17LS
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 58,118
Likes: 2,786
From: Maryland
Default

Originally Posted by Johnhav430
Yeah roads remain salty long after the weather event has passed...I have been thinking about it more and more because I have always been a "hand wash only" person until 2016. I read about LS430s having rust where the plastic is attached on the lower doors. But now, we have monthly car wash memberships on my wife's SUV and the LS. BMW is hand wash only, but the dealer runs it through the car wash every time they have it, and I actually don't see any issues over 11 years.

Anyway, I observed closely this year--there were still cars as of last Friday (maybe today), which had salt all over them. I suspect this means their cars have been covered for minimum 10 days, getting rewet, or worse, about 17-20 days. I clearly remember washing my car on a Mon., where the weather was nice, but the car wash was empty, because the roads were still wet (why wash your car when it literally is rewet upon leaving the wash, right?). It seems to be difficult to be diligent about washing as well, with a hand spray, it's very seldom the right time due to temps...the BMW has not moved out of the garage since 12/20 but I literally washed it at the spray wash that day...
So the secret to salt on your car is moisture, and temp. If its below freezing, the salt won't cause corrosion. Over freezing, it will. I too run my cars through a carwash nowadays, in fact I just ran the LS460L through one yesterday, first time through with 415 miles. I just don't have time to wash them myself, and the weather makes it really unpleasant even if I did. I also don't have time to take them someplace and have detailers wash them and wait, and our lives are too unpredictable to have somebody come here to my house and wash them. If you take the time to find a good carwash, damage to your car will be minimized. The one I use doesn't do any brushing before the cars go in, all their equipment is regularly cleaned, it uses LOTS of sudsy soap (lubricity), they use microfiber towels to dry, no spinning wheel/tire brushes in the tunnel (these are a killer). Keeps my cars a level of swirl free that I can deal with at this stage in my life (not perfect). I spray them down with spray sealant after they're done at the carwash which makes them perfect and drip free, and honestly these days thats the extent of my car care regimen. You know what? They look pretty damn good LOL.

My buddy said I'm ruining the 2006 LS and it's a shame. That car was from FLA and likely garaged, and now it is outside 24/7/365....again the indie pointed out on the lift that this car cannot be from the Northeast as it wouldn't look like that being a 2006. I'm thinking even if it's getting ruined, it has at least a significant delay on the deterioration....
What "ruining"? And, "a shame"? Its a car, a tool. You bought it to drive it and use it where you live, and thats what you're doing. Take as good care of it as you reasonably can. Its not a one of a kind masterpiece or work of art.

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
a 'reasonable person' isn't just all about sucking as much tax dollars out of the system as possible...
Oh its amazing. Imagine the cost of brining every road in Montgomery County (high density, lots of roads) and having to do that TWICE before the same storm. The point of the brine is to have it on the surface when the snow falls, when you do it 2 days before it snows, of course you have to redo it.

This seems to have gotten worse since we had those big snows semi-back to back over a few years. I'm on my HOA board and we have that issue too. We were completely unprepared for the cost of snow removal in those years, and it was 3-4 times more than what our annual budget was which required us to do assessments and raise rates. So now we have a huge snow budget...and no snow. For us its no big deal, unused snow budgets go into the reserve funds and we use that money for improvements and landscaping, etc...but when you look at reducing the budget you wonder, well if we do that will we have another huge snow year again? I'd imagine the same thing is going on at a government level, only they're of course profiting from it themselves which we aren't lol. If they don't use it, they loose it in the next budget.
Old 01-24-18 | 07:48 AM
  #19  
mmarshall's Avatar
mmarshall
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 91,623
Likes: 89
From: Virginia/D.C. suburbs
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
it's pretty simple... you don't see rusty cars in florida.
I'll bet you see plenty near the coast...especially in and around Miami.
Also, consider that today's cars are generally better-equipped to deal wth rust-producing conditions than in the past...that's why we have 5 year/100,000 mile rust-through warranties.
Old 01-24-18 | 08:02 AM
  #20  
SW17LS's Avatar
SW17LS
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 58,118
Likes: 2,786
From: Maryland
Default

Originally Posted by mmarshall
I'll bet you see plenty near the coast...especially in and around Miami..
You do not. I've spent lots of time around water and the ocean, FL, here in MD, in the islands. You don't see rusty cars in the Caribbean, let alone FL.

Heat and humidity cause other potential concerns, as does a high level of salinity in the air, but the type of rusting you're talking about is caused by chemicals used in high concentration to treat winter roads, and is not caused by living near the coast.
Old 01-24-18 | 08:08 AM
  #21  
Johnhav430's Avatar
Johnhav430
Thread Starter
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 8,491
Likes: 372
From: PA
Default

Originally Posted by SW15LS
So the secret to salt on your car is moisture, and temp. If its below freezing, the salt won't cause corrosion. Over freezing, it will. I too run my cars through a carwash nowadays, in fact I just ran the LS460L through one yesterday, first time through with 415 miles. I just don't have time to wash them myself, and the weather makes it really unpleasant even if I did. I also don't have time to take them someplace and have detailers wash them and wait, and our lives are too unpredictable to have somebody come here to my house and wash them. If you take the time to find a good carwash, damage to your car will be minimized. The one I use doesn't do any brushing before the cars go in, all their equipment is regularly cleaned, it uses LOTS of sudsy soap (lubricity), they use microfiber towels to dry, no spinning wheel/tire brushes in the tunnel (these are a killer). Keeps my cars a level of swirl free that I can deal with at this stage in my life (not perfect). I spray them down with spray sealant after they're done at the carwash which makes them perfect and drip free, and honestly these days thats the extent of my car care regimen. You know what? They look pretty damn good LOL.



What "ruining"? And, "a shame"? Its a car, a tool. You bought it to drive it and use it where you live, and thats what you're doing. Take as good care of it as you reasonably can. Its not a one of a kind masterpiece or work of art.



Oh its amazing. Imagine the cost of brining every road in Montgomery County (high density, lots of roads) and having to do that TWICE before the same storm. The point of the brine is to have it on the surface when the snow falls, when you do it 2 days before it snows, of course you have to redo it.

This seems to have gotten worse since we had those big snows semi-back to back over a few years. I'm on my HOA board and we have that issue too. We were completely unprepared for the cost of snow removal in those years, and it was 3-4 times more than what our annual budget was which required us to do assessments and raise rates. So now we have a huge snow budget...and no snow. For us its no big deal, unused snow budgets go into the reserve funds and we use that money for improvements and landscaping, etc...but when you look at reducing the budget you wonder, well if we do that will we have another huge snow year again? I'd imagine the same thing is going on at a government level, only they're of course profiting from it themselves which we aren't lol. If they don't use it, they loose it in the next budget.
My car wash has a guy maybe spraying it as you go in, if you're lucky. Last year, they would take blue tape and tape my sat radio puck that's on the trunk, no longer. The LS has RFID so I just approach, and the gate goes up. Last week, the guy let the car in, in front of me, and walked away! I was gonna blow my horn after 3 min. sitting there lol Another guy saw me and loaded me. My uncle said in every case (he sets them up) a person must press the button for the vehicle to proceed. I thought to myself, because I sat there, I need to take a better look on how that track works...

My wife's has 2 guys wiping with the microfiber on poles, and 4 guys drying at the other end. But a person must manually read the number off the sticker on the windshield, and for some reason they generate a receipt, and tape it outside the car, to show what services to provide? This place does have the local PD's cars, so that must be sweet. My wife's comes out much cleaner, but then you have to (or should) tip the crew....this adds to the monthly.

My buddy is busting on me, he does live in FLA, has a 3 car garage, and had a LS400 (not 430). He says my car deserves to be garaged, but we only have a 1 car garage, occupied by the 335.

As mentioned, I like your area...as a matter of fact, we're headed down this weekend (thank goodness not Super Bowl weekend)....bday party in Rockville. But we'll end up staying overnight in Clarksburg, as our other friends have more room in a newer townhome area. My wife's godson is in Rockville and we attended the christening inside Walter Reed which was really cool.

Anyway, I'd like to see this beet juice in action, but I think it costs more than CaCl?
Old 01-24-18 | 08:45 AM
  #22  
mmarshall's Avatar
mmarshall
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 91,623
Likes: 89
From: Virginia/D.C. suburbs
Default

Originally Posted by SW15LS
You do not. I've spent lots of time around water and the ocean, FL, here in MD, in the islands. You don't see rusty cars in the Caribbean, let alone FL.

Heat and humidity cause other potential concerns, as does a high level of salinity in the air, but the type of rusting you're talking about is caused by chemicals used in high concentration to treat winter roads, and is not caused by living near the coast.

Of course, rust as we know it is limited to iron/steel components (except for galvanized or Stainless-Steel). Many vehicles, today, have non-steel body panels. Salt, though, is still salt....whether you find it in water, water vapor (humidity near the coast), table salt, rock salt, or the brine used in treating roads.

BTW, I agree with you that the salt-powder on the roads here, from all that dried-brine solution, can be a PITA. It is indeed out of control in this area.....primarily because of local politics and the enormous hype in this region from winter storms....can't let a single flake stick to the roads LOL.
Old 01-24-18 | 09:04 AM
  #23  
LeX2K's Avatar
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 20,906
Likes: 3,117
From: Alberta
Default

Originally Posted by mmarshall
Granted, you can't put the hose everywhere, but, if you are diligent with it (as I am), you can get most of it off, most of the time. One problem is that a lot of people simply don't have the patience to (properly) do a thorough hand-wash, both above and on the underpinnings. You don't just go out and do it in 10 or 15 minutes....I usually budget a good 2-3 hours (including drying-time) for a thorough wash/clean-up after driving in salt. And, of course, I simply avoid driving in salt whenever possible or feasible.
The only way to wash ALL the salt off is to get under the car and scrub everything, and even then the salt has probably gotten into areas you can't see or effectively clean. For example you'll need to remove all the wheels to properly clean, clean the brake components as well.

Here in the spring the roads are literally enveloped in clouds of salt drive a freshly detailed car and 5 minutes later it has a film of salt all over it.
Old 01-24-18 | 09:45 AM
  #24  
bitkahuna's Avatar
bitkahuna
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
 
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 75,499
Likes: 2,559
From: Present
Default

Originally Posted by mmarshall
I'll bet you see plenty near the coast...especially in and around Miami.
Also, consider that today's cars are generally better-equipped to deal wth rust-producing conditions than in the past...that's why we have 5 year/100,000 mile rust-through warranties.
if you can't see (or refuse to accept) the difference in results between sea salt in the air and spraying vast quantities of salt directly on hundreds of miles of roads which mixes with snow and gets EVERYWHERE on the underside of vehicles, and if you haven't noticed that vehicles in northern states clearly rust out significantly more quickly than those in sunshines states (humid or not), then i can't help you and further discussion is pointless.
Old 01-24-18 | 10:54 AM
  #25  
LeX2K's Avatar
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 20,906
Likes: 3,117
From: Alberta
Default

A Trabant won't have rust holes in 5 years, corrosion warranties are nearly worthless.
Old 01-24-18 | 12:43 PM
  #26  
mmarshall's Avatar
mmarshall
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 91,623
Likes: 89
From: Virginia/D.C. suburbs
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
if you can't see (or refuse to accept) the difference in results between sea salt in the air and spraying vast quantities of salt directly on hundreds of miles of roads which mixes with snow and gets EVERYWHERE on the underside of vehicles, and if you haven't noticed that vehicles in northern states clearly rust out significantly more quickly than those in sunshines states (humid or not), then i can't help you and further discussion is pointless.
And salt in the air doesn't penetrate everything as well? If you can't see that, then I agree further discussion is pointless.
Old 01-24-18 | 12:57 PM
  #27  
Johnhav430's Avatar
Johnhav430
Thread Starter
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 8,491
Likes: 372
From: PA
Default

Originally Posted by Lexus2000
The only way to wash ALL the salt off is to get under the car and scrub everything, and even then the salt has probably gotten into areas you can't see or effectively clean. For example you'll need to remove all the wheels to properly clean, clean the brake components as well.

Here in the spring the roads are literally enveloped in clouds of salt drive a freshly detailed car and 5 minutes later it has a film of salt all over it.
I asked my uncle, who sets up the car washes. Asked him, should I spend $11/mo. more for the undercarriage wash? He said no. It does something, but not much. It won't do as much as you spraying with a high pressure hose, and even that, cannot get everything off. I think you are totally right about the need to scrub, and think about how impractical if not impossible that is....and if people lease their cars, this isn't even a concern...

edit Again from all I could find on the web, someone said in FLA, if you park on the ocean, and sea water routinely splashes your car, you can identify this rust because it's not on the undercarriage, it's the actual panels of the vehicle rusting. But it only happens if sea water splashes the vehicle, and that's not the majority of cars in FLA (wind helps). The fact that the indie pointed out something about my undercarriage not being typical of the northeast for an 06 told me something. I didn't bring the subject up...he did

Last edited by Johnhav430; 01-24-18 at 01:05 PM.
Old 01-24-18 | 01:12 PM
  #28  
DunWkg's Avatar
DunWkg
Racer
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 1,626
Likes: 27
From: Iowa
Default

One year there was a salt shortage, so a local spice company donated garlic salt. Roads were clear and cars smelled nice too.
Old 01-24-18 | 01:20 PM
  #29  
LeX2K's Avatar
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 20,906
Likes: 3,117
From: Alberta
Default

Originally Posted by Johnhav430
I asked my uncle, who sets up the car washes. Asked him, should I spend $11/mo. more for the undercarriage wash? He said no. It does something, but not much. It won't do as much as you spraying with a high pressure hose, and even that, cannot get everything off. I think you are totally right about the need to scrub, and think about how impractical if not impossible that is....and if people lease their cars, this isn't even a concern...
I own a car that has seen 30 Canadian winters, pressure washing is not good enough to remove winter salt. It will get some but not good enough that stuff clings like crazy, probably because they formulate the stuff so it bonds to the road. Lovely. Here's my winter beater.

https://i.imgur.com/OPYIUmU.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/slLnXRo.jpg

Again from all I could find on the web, someone said in FLA, if you park on the ocean, and sea water routinely splashes your car, you can identify this rust because it's not on the undercarriage, it's the actual panels of the vehicle rusting. But it only happens if sea water splashes the vehicle, and that's not the majority of cars in FLA (wind helps)
Similar in Hawaii, you see cars with rotted out bodies in places you would not expect the upper frames rot from the inside out. The rest of the car is great no rust. Humidity plays a role as well I think.

Best rust prevention is Fluid Film, makes a bit of a mess but one application easily lasts all winter. Nothing with Fluid Film on it will rust plus road salt doesn't seem to like it either, it sticks to the surface but then washes off.
Originally Posted by DunWkg
One year there was a salt shortage, so a local spice company donated garlic salt. Roads were clear and cars smelled nice too.
Is this for real?
Old 01-24-18 | 06:27 PM
  #30  
SW17LS's Avatar
SW17LS
Lexus Fanatic
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 58,118
Likes: 2,786
From: Maryland
Default

Originally Posted by Johnhav430
My wife's comes out much cleaner, but then you have to (or should) tip the crew....this adds to the monthly.
I say with love my friend, but man you are cheap lol

As mentioned, I like your area...as a matter of fact, we're headed down this weekend (thank goodness not Super Bowl weekend)....bday party in Rockville. But we'll end up staying overnight in Clarksburg, as our other friends have more room in a newer townhome area. My wife's godson is in Rockville and we attended the christening inside Walter Reed which was really cool.
Nice! Yeah you won't be far from me at all, I'm in the Kentlands in North Potomac/Gaithersburg a bout 5 miles south of Clarksburg on 270.

One time when you get down here we should link up for lunch or something. I'll get the tip

Originally Posted by mmarshall
And salt in the air doesn't penetrate everything as well? [img]images/smilies/1387914497.gif[/img] If you can't see that, then I agree further discussion is pointless.
Bit is right on here Mike. Its about concentration. How you don't see the difference between salinity in the ambient air and huge quantities of salt being continually driven into the undercarriage of a car from the wheels I truly don't understand...

What do you think does more damage, smoking 30 cigarettes a day directly into your lungs or being in a park everyday next to somebody who is smoking?


Quick Reply: salt damage / beet juice



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:50 PM.