Auto Shifters: Older is Usually Better
#121
Lexus Fanatic
I like the setup in the BMW 7 Series I am considering. The charging tray is behind the cupholders and can be covered.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
#122
Lexus Test Driver
I like the setup in the BMW 7 Series I am considering. The charging tray is behind the cupholders and can be covered.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
#125
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
#126
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (3)
I like the setup in the BMW 7 Series I am considering. The charging tray is behind the cupholders and can be covered.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
I like this setup better than having the charger exposed (I like all that stuff hidden by doors in a luxury car, I hate exposed cupholders etc) or having it under the console lid where all of my junk is going to cover the phone.
#127
Lexus Champion
I'm not saying that one could not (or should not) ever use the cell-phone charger on the console...I occasionally use it myself, especially during a power-failure. But, most of the time, at least for me and others like me, we keep it charged up at home, so that it's ready to go if and when needed. And, yes, I agree, on a long trip, there may be few alternatives. My lifestyle, though, doesn't generally involve long trips anymore...I did enough if them when I was young, and driving long distances was a lot more fun.
Last edited by tex2670; 08-26-20 at 08:25 AM.
#128
#130
I don't get the obsession of hoarding crap in the center console, or the obsession with a bunch of cup holders. I am a minimalist, and I hate having anything I don't need in my car, so I prefer console mounted shifters, and I couldn't care less if they are not space efficient.
#131
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
#132
I agree for sure. Though I so like the zig-zag style that was introduced in the early 2000s. If they're made well, their operation is really smooth, and there's no lock button. I've been very happy with the shifter on my LS430. My Girlfriend has a 2013 Elanta with the same style of shifter. It's not nearly as smooth, but makes up for it with very defined notches between the gears.
These new button style ones just aren't all that great. It'd perhaps work a little better if it were in the style of the original old Dodge Dart. At least make it in a way that most of the gears have a similar button press as opposed to Acura's take of making a different style of button for each gear.
These new button style ones just aren't all that great. It'd perhaps work a little better if it were in the style of the original old Dodge Dart. At least make it in a way that most of the gears have a similar button press as opposed to Acura's take of making a different style of button for each gear.
#133
Driver School Candidate
Shifters
While I had not owned a column shifter in over 30 years (everything manual until getting married in 1989), I do appreciate the one in my 2001 GMC truck. With that shifter, there are zero controls / electronics anywhere near the coffee cup holders or any other common source of debris. Although I am an electronic engineer, I'm not a long term fan of all the electronic interaction because everything will fail at some time. It is generally possible to fix mechanical stuff after manufacturers support goes away, but not so great with electronics. That is one reason that a number of museums that want drivable cars are selling anything really recent. Long term, all the electronics and plastic are major failure points, although 3D printing may help with the later. The Mercedes Classic center advertises that they will support all cars, including the electronics. However, when they have to redesign something due to lack of parts you can stand by for a substantial bill!!
I love the old car simplicity, but do note that anything that had to deal with Fed requirements, like stepping on the brake before start and ability to turn engine off only while in park, are likely to have all kinds of mechanical links. The shift mechanism on my wife's beloved 1998 Volvo S90 is a bit of a mechanical wonder, the design has fortunately been reliable to this point but any substantial parts for that era Volvo are now basically junkyard items. Even parts for my GMC truck are becoming unavailable, particularly for the 8.1 liter big block engine that I love!
I love the old car simplicity, but do note that anything that had to deal with Fed requirements, like stepping on the brake before start and ability to turn engine off only while in park, are likely to have all kinds of mechanical links. The shift mechanism on my wife's beloved 1998 Volvo S90 is a bit of a mechanical wonder, the design has fortunately been reliable to this point but any substantial parts for that era Volvo are now basically junkyard items. Even parts for my GMC truck are becoming unavailable, particularly for the 8.1 liter big block engine that I love!
#135
drives cars
Hmm, let's see, out of the cars my wife and I owned:
See a pattern? All the Toyota/Lexus products are zig-zaggin'. I didn't mind them at all. I've dealt with the BMW shifters and Jaguar's rotary shifter before, and those aren't terrible either. I could get used to them. Push-button ones scare me.
- 2001 Buick Century: column shifter
- 2010 Toyota Camry: zig-zag PRNDL shifter, I believe there was a manual mode to the side.
- 2011 Nissan Versa hatchback: straight PRNDL shifter
- 2015 Toyota Camry: zig-zag PRND, with S to the side
- 2015 Nissan Versa Node: straight PRNDL shifter
- 2016 Lexus IS 300 AWD: zig-zag PRND, with M to the side
- 2016 VW Golf GTI DSG: straight PRNDS shifter, manual mode to the side
See a pattern? All the Toyota/Lexus products are zig-zaggin'. I didn't mind them at all. I've dealt with the BMW shifters and Jaguar's rotary shifter before, and those aren't terrible either. I could get used to them. Push-button ones scare me.