es300 struts/suspension/ NOISE! please help
#1
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: WI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
es300 struts/suspension/ NOISE! please help
Alright.
So going over bumps, potholes, etc has become horrible while driving my ’99 ES300. I notice this/ it seems the worst in the morning on my way to work.
Like a moron, I went and bought new Monroe struts myself and then had my mechanic install them.
This did nothing. I to another mechanic- who I trust much more and they replaced the sway link in the front and the rear- costing total $450.
The next day I noticed that it really didn’t help anything. I go crazy in the morning on my way to work as every little bump sounds terrible and the sunroof is starting to creak a little now (when closed) because of the rattling.
My more-trust-worthy mechanic told me they’d probably have to now replace the following:
1. Mounts
2. Cushion kit
3. Bottom plate
The first mechanic should have replaced the mounts when he did the struts, but he did not even mention that they were bad to me. To replace these three things, my good mechanic is saying it will cost roughly $600 for the front and $600 for the rear- MONROE parts. I checked RockAuto.com (GREAT for parts) and I can’t find everything that is listed above- just the mounts and the plates.
Has anyone else had this problem? I paid $450 to have the struts installed, another $450 for the links and now a rough estimate of $1200...
How much should the parts cost? Worth it? PLEASE HELP! THANKS!!!!!
So going over bumps, potholes, etc has become horrible while driving my ’99 ES300. I notice this/ it seems the worst in the morning on my way to work.
Like a moron, I went and bought new Monroe struts myself and then had my mechanic install them.
This did nothing. I to another mechanic- who I trust much more and they replaced the sway link in the front and the rear- costing total $450.
The next day I noticed that it really didn’t help anything. I go crazy in the morning on my way to work as every little bump sounds terrible and the sunroof is starting to creak a little now (when closed) because of the rattling.
My more-trust-worthy mechanic told me they’d probably have to now replace the following:
1. Mounts
2. Cushion kit
3. Bottom plate
The first mechanic should have replaced the mounts when he did the struts, but he did not even mention that they were bad to me. To replace these three things, my good mechanic is saying it will cost roughly $600 for the front and $600 for the rear- MONROE parts. I checked RockAuto.com (GREAT for parts) and I can’t find everything that is listed above- just the mounts and the plates.
Has anyone else had this problem? I paid $450 to have the struts installed, another $450 for the links and now a rough estimate of $1200...
How much should the parts cost? Worth it? PLEASE HELP! THANKS!!!!!
#2
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: CA
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
how many miles?
How many miles have you on it? I have a 98 with 135k miles and making a clunking noise on pax side over bumps and it turned out to be the strut tower mounts that were worn and loose and required replacing. Search more here for more info.
#6
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: CA
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
strut noise question-98 ES 300
I just replaced all 4 shocks and the top strut tower mounts for poor ride and clunking noise over bumps.
ride now very firm (new shocks?) but now clunking noise recurred but now on drivers side.
Tommy who was reccommended on this form in S. El Monte says that my bottom plate (?mounts) are worn out and also need to be replaced.
He sais earlier just replace top mounts as usually bottom okay. Car has 140k miles on it & trying to keep maintainence costs down as I try to get a few more years out of it.
Should he have originally done both top and bottom mounts?
Any source for lower cost bottom mounts as he says that these have to be Toyota or Lexus parts for this repair?
Thanks
ride now very firm (new shocks?) but now clunking noise recurred but now on drivers side.
Tommy who was reccommended on this form in S. El Monte says that my bottom plate (?mounts) are worn out and also need to be replaced.
He sais earlier just replace top mounts as usually bottom okay. Car has 140k miles on it & trying to keep maintainence costs down as I try to get a few more years out of it.
Should he have originally done both top and bottom mounts?
Any source for lower cost bottom mounts as he says that these have to be Toyota or Lexus parts for this repair?
Thanks
#7
Regional Officer - NTL
iTrader: (1)
It's been proven that staying with the Toyota mounts is the way to go. Lots of folks went aftermarket and have rattling and other noises post-install. If your upper mounts are non-Toyota there's still a chance that they're making noise. Get 'em all while you're at it; they're not THAT expensive and the quiet results are worth it.
Hit up Carson Toyota (see Luis) as they offer amazing prices and discounts for CL members; they're a supporting vendor. Support our supporting vendors whenever possible.
Trending Topics
#8
Alright.
So going over bumps, potholes, etc has become horrible while driving my ’99 ES300. I notice this/ it seems the worst in the morning on my way to work.
Like a moron, I went and bought new Monroe struts myself and then had my mechanic install them.
This did nothing. I to another mechanic- who I trust much more and they replaced the sway link in the front and the rear- costing total $450.
The next day I noticed that it really didn’t help anything. I go crazy in the morning on my way to work as every little bump sounds terrible and the sunroof is starting to creak a little now (when closed) because of the rattling.
My more-trust-worthy mechanic told me they’d probably have to now replace the following:
1. Mounts
2. Cushion kit
3. Bottom plate
The first mechanic should have replaced the mounts when he did the struts, but he did not even mention that they were bad to me. To replace these three things, my good mechanic is saying it will cost roughly $600 for the front and $600 for the rear- MONROE parts. I checked RockAuto.com (GREAT for parts) and I can’t find everything that is listed above- just the mounts and the plates.
Has anyone else had this problem? I paid $450 to have the struts installed, another $450 for the links and now a rough estimate of $1200...
How much should the parts cost? Worth it? PLEASE HELP! THANKS!!!!!
So going over bumps, potholes, etc has become horrible while driving my ’99 ES300. I notice this/ it seems the worst in the morning on my way to work.
Like a moron, I went and bought new Monroe struts myself and then had my mechanic install them.
This did nothing. I to another mechanic- who I trust much more and they replaced the sway link in the front and the rear- costing total $450.
The next day I noticed that it really didn’t help anything. I go crazy in the morning on my way to work as every little bump sounds terrible and the sunroof is starting to creak a little now (when closed) because of the rattling.
My more-trust-worthy mechanic told me they’d probably have to now replace the following:
1. Mounts
2. Cushion kit
3. Bottom plate
The first mechanic should have replaced the mounts when he did the struts, but he did not even mention that they were bad to me. To replace these three things, my good mechanic is saying it will cost roughly $600 for the front and $600 for the rear- MONROE parts. I checked RockAuto.com (GREAT for parts) and I can’t find everything that is listed above- just the mounts and the plates.
Has anyone else had this problem? I paid $450 to have the struts installed, another $450 for the links and now a rough estimate of $1200...
How much should the parts cost? Worth it? PLEASE HELP! THANKS!!!!!
Chris
#9
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (1)
My 2002 ES developed a clunk sound that was similar to a couple of golf ***** banging around in the spare tire well every time I hit a bump.
Turned out to be the rear sway bar bushings. Two $10 pieces of rubber and 30 minutes of my time to totally silence the rear end. This is the most common cause of Toyota/Lexus noise in the rear end.
Later the front started to make the same noise. Replaced the front sway bar bushings (about 3 hours of my time cause they are harder to get at). This wasn't it. Turned out to be the left front strut nut (up under the hood) has lossened a 1/2 a turn. Tightened and the noise was gone.
steviej
Turned out to be the rear sway bar bushings. Two $10 pieces of rubber and 30 minutes of my time to totally silence the rear end. This is the most common cause of Toyota/Lexus noise in the rear end.
Later the front started to make the same noise. Replaced the front sway bar bushings (about 3 hours of my time cause they are harder to get at). This wasn't it. Turned out to be the left front strut nut (up under the hood) has lossened a 1/2 a turn. Tightened and the noise was gone.
steviej
#10
Did you have to also apply some lubricant in the bushings when you installed them, so they don't make the sweaking noise?
#13
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: WI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I want to order the parts from Carson and have my mechanic put them in... any idea what I all need to buy? Should I JUST get the strut MOUNTS? Or do I need any of the other parts on here:
http://www.trademotion.com/partlocat...layCatalogid=0
?
THANKS
http://www.trademotion.com/partlocat...layCatalogid=0
?
THANKS
#14
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: WI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok,
I just ordered my parts from Luis at Carson (he said I was getting a discount, but the prices were the same as their prices on their website)... at any rate I have a question and hope someone sees this that can answer.
When I was looking online, there was a 'strut mount' for the front at about $70- give or take. Luis told me that for the front mount, I needed to buy three separate parts: the seat, support and bearing because they didn't make an "all-in-one" mount, but they do make it for the back ($96 ea. side)..
Does that sound right? Do I have to buy all three parts (for each front side) Or could I just have bought the front "mount" for $70?
I just ordered my parts from Luis at Carson (he said I was getting a discount, but the prices were the same as their prices on their website)... at any rate I have a question and hope someone sees this that can answer.
When I was looking online, there was a 'strut mount' for the front at about $70- give or take. Luis told me that for the front mount, I needed to buy three separate parts: the seat, support and bearing because they didn't make an "all-in-one" mount, but they do make it for the back ($96 ea. side)..
Does that sound right? Do I have to buy all three parts (for each front side) Or could I just have bought the front "mount" for $70?
#15
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: va
Posts: 28
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
steviej: how did you tighten the strut nut? i have the same issue with with front passenger strut nut being loose, but when i try to tighten the nut it just spins (doesnt tighten) and i noticed the strut piston spins as well. any ideas?