EV Chat General discussion about electrified Lexus, other EV vehicle manufacturers and BEV, PHEV related industry news.

Tesla appears to be turning back to radar for its vehicles

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 12-08-22, 06:26 AM
  #1  
Hoovey689
Moderator
Thread Starter
iTrader: (16)
 
Hoovey689's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: California
Posts: 42,302
Received 125 Likes on 83 Posts
Default Tesla appears to be turning back to radar for its vehicles

It began removing radar from its vehicles last May



Tesla plans to add a new radar product to its vehicles in mid-January, according to documents posted with the Federal Communications Commission.

The disclosure, which was first reported by Electrek, comes as the company faces scrutiny over the safety and capabilities of its standard advanced driver assistance system known as Autopilot and the $15,000 optional upgraded product branded as "Full Self-Driving." Tesla FSD beta software offers some automated driving features but is not a self-driving system.

The luxury EV-maker has long claimed it could reach full autonomy through a "vision only" approach that shuns other sensors like lidar and radar in favor of cameras and a deep neural network that quickly processes a vehicle's surroundings and responds in real time. Tesla CEO Elon Musk previously promised to "solve" full self-driving by the end of this year (he's also promised Tesla would get there every year for roughly nine years now). He has recently admitted the problem will take longer to solve.

And perhaps, as every other autonomous vehicle technologist says, it's not actually achievable yet through cameras alone.

The company began removing radar from its vehicles last May. In October, Tesla removed its 12 ultrasonic sensors from Model 3 and Model Y vehicles built for North America, Europe, the Middle East and Taiwan. Ultrasonic sensors measure distance via ultrasonic waves and are used as proximity sensors to support anti-collision safety systems, particularly in parking use cases.

Now it appears radar is back. It's not yet clear which models will get the new radar. The type of radar Tesla intends to market next year is of a frequency that's allocated by the FCC for ADAS use cases, according to Ram Machness, chief business officer at Arbe Robotics, which produces ultra-high-resolution 4D imaging radar.

Tesla had originally filed with the FCC to use the new radar — which is described in filings as "76-77 GHz Automotive Radar" — in its vehicles back in June.

"From the frequency of operation (76-77GHz) as well as the mechanical design of the sensor from Tesla’s FCC filing, it appears that this radar would be utilized in ADAS applications," Steven Hong, VP and general manager of radar technology at semiconductor company Ambarella, told TechCrunch.

He noted that while the performance of this 'edge' radar sensor will be limited, it's a positive development that Tesla is looking to add radar to its perception stack for safety-critical, robust performance.

Earlier this year, the FCC had granted a confidential treatment to Tesla in order to keep the details of the new radar under wraps. Late last month, Tesla applied to extend that confidentiality treatment another 60 days from its date of expiration, which is December 7.

The authorization letter to the FCC reads: "... this device will not be marketed until Mid-January 2023. To avoid any unnecessary disclosure and competitive harm before our product launching, we would like to request above exhibits to be held for another 60 days until 2023-02-07."

The FCC filings show that the regulator has granted Tesla's request for extended confidentiality.
Source
Old 12-08-22, 06:35 AM
  #2  
bitkahuna
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
 
bitkahuna's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Present
Posts: 74,898
Received 2,439 Likes on 1,599 Posts
Default

The authorization letter to the FCC reads: "... this device will not be marketed until Mid-January 2023. To avoid any unnecessary disclosure and competitive harm before our product launching, we would like to request above exhibits to be held for another 60 days until 2023-02-07."
that part is quite interesting.

as for going back to radar... well duh, cameras suck at night for one thing, can't see through fog, etc.
Old 12-08-22, 08:49 AM
  #3  
AMIRZA786
Lexus Champion
 
AMIRZA786's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: California
Posts: 13,800
Received 2,150 Likes on 1,672 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
that part is quite interesting.

as for going back to radar... well duh, cameras suck at night for one thing, can't see through fog, etc.
I believe they did a lot of testing, and they didn't need radar. I believe it's more a Federal mandate because of FSD. I'll see if I can dig up where I read that to confirm. But you are correct, I would be scared of a camera getting covered in gook or broken, or not seeing properly at night because of glare or fogging

Last edited by AMIRZA786; 12-08-22 at 09:02 AM.
Old 12-08-22, 09:42 AM
  #4  
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
LeX2K's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Alberta
Posts: 20,207
Received 2,933 Likes on 2,470 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by AMIRZA786
But you are correct, I would be scared of a camera getting covered in gook or broken, or not seeing properly at night because of glare or fogging
How many of the 8 cameras need to be covered up before FSD won't be able to see? Here is FSD being driven in Calgary the system makes quite a few mistakes but in general seeing the road isn't an issue. Radar would not help at all to see lane lines. From what I've seen FSD is 95% software challenged 5% vision challenged.


In heavy rain and fog maybe radar would help but is prone to phantom signals.
Old 12-08-22, 09:52 AM
  #5  
AMIRZA786
Lexus Champion
 
AMIRZA786's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: California
Posts: 13,800
Received 2,150 Likes on 1,672 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by LeX2K
How many of the 8 cameras need to be covered up before FSD won't be able to see? Here is FSD being driven in Calgary the system makes quite a few mistakes but in general seeing the road isn't an issue. Radar would not help at all to see lane lines. From what I've seen FSD is 95% software challenged 5% vision challenged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZ-WDkxibPo

In heavy rain and fog maybe radar would help but is prone to phantom signals.
You don't have to convince me. I drove my brother in laws Model 3 at night, and it saw everything around me, including a pedestrian crossing all the way on the left side, and a bicyclist. I believe it's NTSB mandating radar for FSD. Not 100 percent sure, but I think that's what it is

Last edited by AMIRZA786; 12-08-22 at 09:55 AM.
Old 12-08-22, 10:06 AM
  #6  
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
LeX2K's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Alberta
Posts: 20,207
Received 2,933 Likes on 2,470 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by AMIRZA786
You don't have to convince me. I drove my brother in laws Model 3 at night, and it saw everything around me, including a pedestrian crossing all the way on the left side, and a bicyclist. I believe it's NTSB mandating radar for FSD. Not 100 percent sure, but I think that's what it is
Very possible. Let's see what kind of radar unit Tesla has come up with they try very hard not to put parts in cars that don't do anything.

Tesla will probably steal this idea if they haven't thought of it, I want to see a radar unit output the same signal as a vision camera. That way FSD treats it just like any other camera but the radar version is seeing past things like rain and fog. Maybe this is not technically possible but I envision the radar signal being processed to an output just like a photon sensor camera. This solves the problem of phantom objects because the radar, let's now call it vadar, camera is mixed in with the rest of the cameras. FSD using the total image construct can easily determined if the vadar unit is being stupid because the rest of the cameras will be correct. Vision is never wrong unless it is obscured/blocked.

Old 12-08-22, 10:15 AM
  #7  
AMIRZA786
Lexus Champion
 
AMIRZA786's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: California
Posts: 13,800
Received 2,150 Likes on 1,672 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by LeX2K
Very possible. Let's see what kind of radar unit Tesla has come up with they try very hard not to put parts in cars that don't do anything.

Tesla will probably steal this idea if they haven't thought of it, I want to see a radar unit output the same signal as a vision camera. That way FSD treats it just like any other camera but the radar version is seeing past things like rain and fog. Maybe this is not technically possible but I envision the radar signal being processed to an output just like a photon sensor camera. This solves the problem of phantom objects because the radar, let's now call it vadar, camera is mixed in with the rest of the cameras. FSD using the total image construct can easily determined if the vadar unit is being stupid because the rest of the cameras will be correct. Vision is never wrong unless it is obscured/blocked.
You're talking way, way above my head LOL. That said, they may require the radar for cars that have FSD. My brother in law actually got an email from Tesla (before his car was delivered) that they moved to all optical and he had to re-approve the order. He opted not to get FSD, even though they offered it to him for $6K instead of $15K. Since that's the case, he may not have to worry about not having radar
Old 12-08-22, 10:24 AM
  #8  
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
LeX2K's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Alberta
Posts: 20,207
Received 2,933 Likes on 2,470 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by AMIRZA786
You're talking way, way above my head LOL. That said, they may require the radar for cars that have FSD. My brother in law actually got an email from Tesla (before his car was delivered) that they moved to all optical and he had to re-approve the order. He opted not to get FSD, even though they offered it to him for $6K instead of $15K. Since that's the case, he may not have to worry about not having radar
Interesting. $6K would have been an excellent investment IMO when FSD is solved (it will be, eventually) it will be worth far more.

AI driving is insanely difficult Argo (VW sponsored) recently shut down Lucid has a zillion sensors but no software to go with it.
Old 12-08-22, 10:29 AM
  #9  
AMIRZA786
Lexus Champion
 
AMIRZA786's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: California
Posts: 13,800
Received 2,150 Likes on 1,672 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by LeX2K
Interesting. $6K would have been an excellent investment IMO when FSD is solved (it will be, eventually) it will be worth far more.

AI driving is insanely difficult Argo (VW sponsored) recently shut down Lucid has a zillion sensors but no software to go with it.
He was considering it, but the Tesla rep said that eventually they will add it as a subscription. TBH, I most likely will opt not to get it when I eventually get my Model 3
Old 12-08-22, 10:30 AM
  #10  
LeX2K
Lexus Fanatic
 
LeX2K's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Alberta
Posts: 20,207
Received 2,933 Likes on 2,470 Posts
Default

You can buy it at any time, or opt to pay as you go. Owning the software may go away though not sure.
Old 12-08-22, 12:31 PM
  #11  
bitkahuna
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
 
bitkahuna's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Present
Posts: 74,898
Received 2,439 Likes on 1,599 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by LeX2K
Owning the software may go away though not sure.
car owner doesn't own the software, that's for sure, just a license to use.

Old 12-08-22, 12:36 PM
  #12  
AMIRZA786
Lexus Champion
 
AMIRZA786's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: California
Posts: 13,800
Received 2,150 Likes on 1,672 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
car owner doesn't own the software, that's for sure, just a license to use.
I listen to Rob Mower from Tesla Daily, and he mentioned in one of his videos that if you buy the software you own it, and if it ever leaves beta and Tesla decides to charge more for it, you will own it as an early Beta tester. I don't know to what extent that is, can you transfer it to another Tesla later on? Dunno
Old 12-08-22, 12:43 PM
  #13  
Toys4RJill
Lexus Fanatic
 
Toys4RJill's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: ON/NY
Posts: 31,184
Received 64 Likes on 55 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by bitkahuna
car owner doesn't own the software, that's for sure, just a license to use.
Tesla can also brick you. Over the air updates are a terrible idea.
Old 12-10-22, 04:53 AM
  #14  
corradoMR2
The pursuit of F
 
corradoMR2's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 8,296
Received 296 Likes on 215 Posts
Default

Well, I'm glad they're adding it back as I don't see how the car, in even the lightest mode of autonomous driving, can operate safely with just cameras.

Even with the radar sensors in my 3, the car sometimes struggles in snowy weather, rain, fog, and even bright sun shining in any one of the cameras. The car will not engage (or suddenly disengage) in just the most basic autopilot in any one of these scenarios. Still a long way to go for true FSD.
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Hoovey689
Car Chat
3
03-23-22 07:49 PM
Hoovey689
Car Chat
4
10-07-21 10:10 AM



Quick Reply: Tesla appears to be turning back to radar for its vehicles



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:24 PM.