Originally Posted by Och

Completely forgot to update this one... We got the car started the following day.

What happened was, there is a rubber o-ring on the old filter. The new filter didnt come with that ring and we overlooked it. Took that ring from the old filter, put it on the new filter, and the car started right up.

And just for everyone's info, the fuel filter replacement job is not difficult, but very stinky. Do it in a well ventilated area and have a bunch of disposable towels ready.