Knocking from engine bay
#1
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2021
Location: Arizona
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Knocking from engine bay
Hi this is my first post so please bear with me. I have a 2010 is350c with 205k miles and recently got an oil change 5 30.
about 2 weeks ago i was driving and my engine shut off out of nowhere and turned back on a second later, followed by cel flashing and misfiring, i was about 5minutes from home so i was able to pull the code, cylinder 2 misfire, swapped out the ignition coil for cylinder 2 and that was that. Fast forward a few minutes i let it idle and warm up and it began knocking very loudly and my rpms kept dropping and even dropped till my engine shut off one time. Now when i start it up cold it knocks for a few seconds then dies off until its warm and the knocking picks right back up with any throttle given, the knocking does increase with the throttle. I have searched all throughout this forum and cant seem to find anyone who has the same knocking issue. I will attach a video showing the noise it makes. Any insight is appreciated, if i cant find a fix here my next course of action is to tow it to a dealer.
edit: i also added half a bottle of oil stabilizer which helped for a few minutes before the sound resumed
about 2 weeks ago i was driving and my engine shut off out of nowhere and turned back on a second later, followed by cel flashing and misfiring, i was about 5minutes from home so i was able to pull the code, cylinder 2 misfire, swapped out the ignition coil for cylinder 2 and that was that. Fast forward a few minutes i let it idle and warm up and it began knocking very loudly and my rpms kept dropping and even dropped till my engine shut off one time. Now when i start it up cold it knocks for a few seconds then dies off until its warm and the knocking picks right back up with any throttle given, the knocking does increase with the throttle. I have searched all throughout this forum and cant seem to find anyone who has the same knocking issue. I will attach a video showing the noise it makes. Any insight is appreciated, if i cant find a fix here my next course of action is to tow it to a dealer.
edit: i also added half a bottle of oil stabilizer which helped for a few minutes before the sound resumed
Last edited by FnathanF; 12-24-21 at 04:55 PM. Reason: Additional info for post
#2
Instructor
That sounds like piston slap and that's not a good thing. Have you checked your oil level since the change? I'll ask some more basic questions because you just got an oil change and I'm guessing you haven't been under the car since then.
Is there an oil filter installed?
Look at the part number - is it the original filter which sits inside a housing or is it some metallic oil filter (I hope not!)
Is the oil pan drain plug in place?
Do you see oil all under the chassis?
Is there an oil filter installed?
Look at the part number - is it the original filter which sits inside a housing or is it some metallic oil filter (I hope not!)
Is the oil pan drain plug in place?
Do you see oil all under the chassis?
#3
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2021
Location: Arizona
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The engine oil is just a bit above the top line probably due to the oil additive shortly after the oil change. Visually i can not see any oil underneath the car, as for the other questions i do not have access to a jack currently, if im able to get a hold of one soon i will update with responses to the other questions.
#4
Instructor
If the oil is above the top line then most of my questions are moot. Still that noise is scary and sounds like piston slap. I hope I'm wrong and there is some other cheaper remedy. Next thought is the oil filter that might have been wrong. Good luck.
#5
Might also be a loose spark plug (had that happen in a 2007 RX400h).
Check every spark plug is torqued to spec. Remove each plug while you’re at it to check them for degradation and/or damage.
Check every spark plug is torqued to spec. Remove each plug while you’re at it to check them for degradation and/or damage.
#7
Lexus Fanatic
Based on the 7 seconds of video, rod knock.
Trending Topics
#8
Lexus Test Driver
iTrader: (2)
Hi this is my first post so please bear with me. I have a 2010 is350c with 205k miles and recently got an oil change 5 30.
about 2 weeks ago i was driving and my engine shut off out of nowhere and turned back on a second later, followed by cel flashing and misfiring, i was about 5minutes from home so i was able to pull the code, cylinder 2 misfire, swapped out the ignition coil for cylinder 2 and that was that. Fast forward a few minutes i let it idle and warm up and it began knocking very loudly and my rpms kept dropping and even dropped till my engine shut off one time. Now when i start it up cold it knocks for a few seconds then dies off until its warm and the knocking picks right back up with any throttle given, the knocking does increase with the throttle. I have searched all throughout this forum and cant seem to find anyone who has the same knocking issue. I will attach a video showing the noise it makes. Any insight is appreciated, if i cant find a fix here my next course of action is to tow it to a dealer.
edit: i also added half a bottle of oil stabilizer which helped for a few minutes before the sound resumed
Video of sound
about 2 weeks ago i was driving and my engine shut off out of nowhere and turned back on a second later, followed by cel flashing and misfiring, i was about 5minutes from home so i was able to pull the code, cylinder 2 misfire, swapped out the ignition coil for cylinder 2 and that was that. Fast forward a few minutes i let it idle and warm up and it began knocking very loudly and my rpms kept dropping and even dropped till my engine shut off one time. Now when i start it up cold it knocks for a few seconds then dies off until its warm and the knocking picks right back up with any throttle given, the knocking does increase with the throttle. I have searched all throughout this forum and cant seem to find anyone who has the same knocking issue. I will attach a video showing the noise it makes. Any insight is appreciated, if i cant find a fix here my next course of action is to tow it to a dealer.
edit: i also added half a bottle of oil stabilizer which helped for a few minutes before the sound resumed
Video of sound
Take a long wood dowel, stethoscope, or even a long screwdriver and place one end to your ear and probe about the top and side of block, be wise of belt but listen to everything. Report back where the sound is coming from.
FWIW most often a failed rod bearing will be quite while the crankshaft is accelerated and pound or rattle when you let off the throttle. If that is the case, pull the oil filter cartridge and look in the pleats for metal.
Maybe post a longer video of cold start, cut to warm up?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post