Complete IS-F Brake Thread (Under-construction)
#436
Intermediate
So, I probably wont need new rotors for a little longer, but I am trying to have everything ready so that I dont have to scramble to get parts when the time comes. I have been trying to shop around and look at the different rotor options, but I am not finding a whole lot. Right now, I am just running the stock rotors and project Mu ns-400 pads. I have about 15k miles on those pads so far and I absolutely love them. They never make a sound and I dont have anywhere near the dusting issues I did with the OEM pads. I plan to continue running those and I just recently ordered a new set for a pretty amazing price (thanks to Lou from ModInJapan).
I have no complaints with the stock rotors and I think they look pretty great, but I cant seem to find replacements online and I am sure that a lexus dealership would mark them up outrageously. Does anyone know the part numbers for those or where I could get my hands on them?
I am also completely open to suggestions for aftermarket rotors. I know a lot of you guys are running the figs 2-piece setup, but I wasn't really planning on spending 2grand+ on rotors. I know there is a pretty substantial weight reduction, but I am not really sure that these would be necessary for my daily driving purposes.
any suggestions are greatly appreciated.
I have no complaints with the stock rotors and I think they look pretty great, but I cant seem to find replacements online and I am sure that a lexus dealership would mark them up outrageously. Does anyone know the part numbers for those or where I could get my hands on them?
I am also completely open to suggestions for aftermarket rotors. I know a lot of you guys are running the figs 2-piece setup, but I wasn't really planning on spending 2grand+ on rotors. I know there is a pretty substantial weight reduction, but I am not really sure that these would be necessary for my daily driving purposes.
any suggestions are greatly appreciated.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Lexus-IS-F-0...9XOriG&vxp=mtr
#437
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (9)
^^^^I'm part of most of the members and have not bought from that seller, but read this thread:
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-...bo-rotors.html
Lou
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-...bo-rotors.html
Lou
The following users liked this post:
wrenca91 (06-28-17)
#438
Driver School Candidate
^^^^I'm part of most of the members and have not bought from that seller, but read this thread:
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-...bo-rotors.html
Lou
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-...bo-rotors.html
Lou
#439
#441
Racer
iTrader: (5)
I have the HC+800 all around, just as Lance stated, I have the same experience with occasional grinding noise, the rear is somehow completely silent.
I currently have an awesome experience with the Ferodo DS2500 on my Cayenne GTS. The pad is very strong with an exceptional feel and zero noise.
So for my ISF, as soon as my front HC+800 pads are shot, I will go with the same setup Lou has. Ferodo DS2500 in the font and continue having the Project Mu HC+800 in the rear.
I find it to be the ultimate setup performance-wise without the grinding sound and I believe much easier on my 2pc rotors. BTW, the dust level on the Project mu is off the charts,
which I don't really care about as I choose performance over dust, but it is insane just so you know. On the other hand, Ferodo DS2500 are somewhat less dust than OEM to my personal surprise.
I currently have an awesome experience with the Ferodo DS2500 on my Cayenne GTS. The pad is very strong with an exceptional feel and zero noise.
So for my ISF, as soon as my front HC+800 pads are shot, I will go with the same setup Lou has. Ferodo DS2500 in the font and continue having the Project Mu HC+800 in the rear.
I find it to be the ultimate setup performance-wise without the grinding sound and I believe much easier on my 2pc rotors. BTW, the dust level on the Project mu is off the charts,
which I don't really care about as I choose performance over dust, but it is insane just so you know. On the other hand, Ferodo DS2500 are somewhat less dust than OEM to my personal surprise.
I will update with my personal feedback after the install. I know this pad really well from my other car, I think this is it ..... perfect balance between strong performance and drivability.
http://speedfreaksusa.com/i-10417288...rake-pads.html
#442
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (1)
Just ordered a set of front Ferodo DS2500 from Matt, very excited as these should be the ultimate front brake pad in combination with the rear ProjectMu HC+ 800.
I will update with my personal feedback after the install. I know this pad really well from my other car, I think this is it ..... perfect balance between strong performance and drivability.
http://speedfreaksusa.com/i-10417288...rake-pads.html
I will update with my personal feedback after the install. I know this pad really well from my other car, I think this is it ..... perfect balance between strong performance and drivability.
http://speedfreaksusa.com/i-10417288...rake-pads.html
-Matt M.
#444
Racer
iTrader: (5)
Just ordered a set of front Ferodo DS2500 from Matt, very excited as these should be the ultimate front brake pad in combination with the rear ProjectMu HC+ 800.
I will update with my personal feedback after the install. I know this pad really well from my other car, I think this is it ..... perfect balance between strong performance and drivability.
http://speedfreaksusa.com/i-10417288...rake-pads.html
I will update with my personal feedback after the install. I know this pad really well from my other car, I think this is it ..... perfect balance between strong performance and drivability.
http://speedfreaksusa.com/i-10417288...rake-pads.html
I have the HC+800 all around, just as Lance stated, I have the same experience with occasional grinding noise, the rear is somehow completely silent.
I currently have an awesome experience with the Ferodo DS2500 on my Cayenne GTS. The pad is very strong with an exceptional feel and zero noise.
So for my ISF, as soon as my front HC+800 pads are shot, I will go with the same setup Lou has. Ferodo DS2500 in the font and continue having the Project Mu HC+800 in the rear.
I find it to be the ultimate setup performance-wise without the grinding sound and I believe much easier on my 2pc rotors. BTW, the dust level on the Project mu is off the charts,
which I don't really care about as I choose performance over dust, but it is insane just so you know. On the other hand, Ferodo DS2500 are somewhat less dust than OEM to my personal surprise.
I currently have an awesome experience with the Ferodo DS2500 on my Cayenne GTS. The pad is very strong with an exceptional feel and zero noise.
So for my ISF, as soon as my front HC+800 pads are shot, I will go with the same setup Lou has. Ferodo DS2500 in the font and continue having the Project Mu HC+800 in the rear.
I find it to be the ultimate setup performance-wise without the grinding sound and I believe much easier on my 2pc rotors. BTW, the dust level on the Project mu is off the charts,
which I don't really care about as I choose performance over dust, but it is insane just so you know. On the other hand, Ferodo DS2500 are somewhat less dust than OEM to my personal surprise.
IMO these Ferodo DS2500 are best pads for the money if you want top notch performance without any of the race pad non-sense, like noise, grind and dust.
Yes, very strong and still quite a workload for the stock ABS system to keep up, as it is not that hard to lock the front wheels :-) The biggest difference over the PM800s is no more grinding noise when slowing down in high speeds, no squealing when going very slow after the long drive. Pretty much no grinding or any other noise. I was advised to re-bed the Project Mu's so many times, they lasted less than 10K. Yes, Ferodo pads might be little bit pricier, but worth every penny. 60-70% less dust (no exaggeration) than Project Mu HC800 + in dust on my front wheels. They also dust less than OEM Brembo pads, just to mention as not everyone runs Project Mu HC800+.
It is like the new pads smoothed the the rotors. I have never seen that before.
Just my two cents, high performance braking can be as much fun as accelerating. Enjoy!
The following users liked this post:
mikersoft (10-24-17)
#446
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jun 2017
Location: Ontario
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can the DS2500 perform double duty street and track like the HC800+?
I'm about to get the HC800+ front and rear for double duty (2-3 track days per year) cause I'm getting lazier as I age but if the DS2500 can do the same with less bedding in issues, grinding noise and dust then I'm up for that.
I'm about to get the HC800+ front and rear for double duty (2-3 track days per year) cause I'm getting lazier as I age but if the DS2500 can do the same with less bedding in issues, grinding noise and dust then I'm up for that.
#447
Lexus Test Driver
iTrader: (1)
Let me start with, I am finished looking, unless Ferodo come up with the rear set for our cars, then Ferodo DS2500 front pads and Project Mu HC800+ rear pads will be my combo for as long as I own the F. I would like to thank Matt from SpeedFreaksUSA, just the best place to get your pads from. Thank you!
I am back with my feedback about the front Ferodo DS2500 pads installed. Just as anticipated, very strong pad. Right on par with the Project MU HC+ 800 pads I removed.
IMO these Ferodo DS2500 are best pads for the money if you want top notch performance without any of the race pad non-sense, like noise, grind and dust.
Yes, very strong and still quite a workload for the stock ABS system to keep up, as it is not that hard to lock the front wheels :-) The biggest difference over the PM800s is no more grinding noise when slowing down in high speeds, no squealing when going very slow after the long drive. Pretty much no grinding or any other noise. I was advised to re-bed the Project Mu's so many times, they lasted less than 10K. Yes, Ferodo pads might be little bit pricier, but worth every penny. 60-70% less dust (no exaggeration) than Project Mu HC800 + in dust on my front wheels. They also dust less than OEM Brembo pads, just to mention as not everyone runs Project Mu HC800+.
Yes, the Project Mu HC 800+ did not go easy on my front rotors, the new Ferodo's are way better in this regard. Its is strange, but after 500 miles the front rotors are way smoother than before.
It is like the new pads smoothed the the rotors. I have never seen that before.
Just my two cents, high performance braking can be as much fun as accelerating. Enjoy!
I am back with my feedback about the front Ferodo DS2500 pads installed. Just as anticipated, very strong pad. Right on par with the Project MU HC+ 800 pads I removed.
IMO these Ferodo DS2500 are best pads for the money if you want top notch performance without any of the race pad non-sense, like noise, grind and dust.
Yes, very strong and still quite a workload for the stock ABS system to keep up, as it is not that hard to lock the front wheels :-) The biggest difference over the PM800s is no more grinding noise when slowing down in high speeds, no squealing when going very slow after the long drive. Pretty much no grinding or any other noise. I was advised to re-bed the Project Mu's so many times, they lasted less than 10K. Yes, Ferodo pads might be little bit pricier, but worth every penny. 60-70% less dust (no exaggeration) than Project Mu HC800 + in dust on my front wheels. They also dust less than OEM Brembo pads, just to mention as not everyone runs Project Mu HC800+.
Yes, the Project Mu HC 800+ did not go easy on my front rotors, the new Ferodo's are way better in this regard. Its is strange, but after 500 miles the front rotors are way smoother than before.
It is like the new pads smoothed the the rotors. I have never seen that before.
Just my two cents, high performance braking can be as much fun as accelerating. Enjoy!
Thanks for the detailed write up.. I'm interested in an alternative to the HC+800 for two reasons: 1.) Less wear on my front rotors 2.) Less dust during daily driving
The HC+800 seem to be pretty brutal on my front rotors as well.. I'm using the RR Racing two-piece (disks made by Coleman, if I'm not mistaken). However, I'm concerned about the potential delta in operating temps that I see for the Ferodos vs. PMUs. Though, the specs I see on each manufacturer's website may not be an apples to apples comparison.
DS2500: Average friction coefficient of 0.42 over working temperature range of 20°-500°C
HC+800: Applicable Rotor Temperature: 0~800℃
Matt, can you help clarify the operating temps between these pads? As you may recall, I get my pads pretty hot at the track, so I want to make sure I'm not stepping down in the performance category with another pad. I'm also interested in the Endless MX72 as well. I know the Endless pads are very pricey, but they may be worth the extra $$ if I can get the same performance/longevity at the track, without all that dust on the street.. Thanks.
-Mike
#448
Pole Position
Mike^^^^^^^^^I've been running Endless MX72's for over 2 years now and won't run another pad as long as they're made! Ask Matt as Speed Freaks what he prefers, but he stays off the MX72 topic most of the time because nobody likes the price?
It's never made sense to me why some would cheap out on brake pads, but then they'll pony up for Michelin tires (why... because Michelins tend to be better but you pay for quality)?? To each there own but after you experience a good pad like the MX72's you won't consider anything else. Just like when I purchased my PSS's (I was skeptical on the price/performance quotient) I came to the realization that they were worth the price of admission. I will probably stay a Michelin customer for a long time even though you pay more $$ for them, I think the same formula applies to pads?
Just my 2 cents
It's never made sense to me why some would cheap out on brake pads, but then they'll pony up for Michelin tires (why... because Michelins tend to be better but you pay for quality)?? To each there own but after you experience a good pad like the MX72's you won't consider anything else. Just like when I purchased my PSS's (I was skeptical on the price/performance quotient) I came to the realization that they were worth the price of admission. I will probably stay a Michelin customer for a long time even though you pay more $$ for them, I think the same formula applies to pads?
Just my 2 cents
Last edited by MileHIFcar; 10-26-17 at 02:57 PM.
The following users liked this post:
mikersoft (10-26-17)
#449
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (1)
Sorry for the late reply, fellas. I took a bit of long weekend for F1 and stayed in Austin a few extra days to check out the area (it's a great place especially if you're into tacos and BBQ ) Anyway it's back to work now.
Thank you for the kind words, Ross! I am so happy to hear you're loving those DS2500 up front with the HC+800 in the rear. It really seems like they are perfect for what you want out of your pads. Between the very positive feedback from both you and Lou it sounds like the balance is just fine with the HC+800 in the rear as well. We thought it would be looking at it on paper but it's always reassuring to have that validated in the real world.
It sounds DS2500/HC+800 could be the new go-to combination for the guys who want to use their cars aggressively on the street but may not take their car to the track as frequently and/or would prefer a little more street civility without making the jump all the way to Endless.
You've been using that combination for quite a while now. How many miles have you put on them? Any feedback on the wear rates from your use?
Yes, absolutely DS2500 can perform double duty for the majority of people but all pads are a compromise and it's about choosing where and how much you're okay with compromising. I have used the DS2500 on track just to see what would happen and they held up fairly well but I still think the HC+800 is the better of the two for track events. The biggest difference between the two is in the temperature ceiling, with the HC+800 being able to operate a fair bit hotter than the Ferodos. The drawback of most pad compounds designed to operate at such a high temp range is that they are generally more abrasive and dustier at lower temp ranges (as Ross noticed when switching). With that being said the IS-F has great brakes standard which are pretty effective at shedding heat on track relative to the car's abilities so you may be able to get away with the DS2500 on track just fine depending on the tracks you drive, your own abilities, the tires etc.
If you're only doing 2-3 events per year you may want to start off with the DS2500 since they will be a bit more street friendly than the HC+800 and that is where the car will be spending the majority of the time. If you know you're going to absolutely punish your brakes on track and don't mind the dust then the HC+800 are not a bad way to start out either.
You are correct that the data published between manufactures is not always apples to apples- some manufactures (I see it more commonly with the budget brands) will fudge the numbers to make it appear like they have a superior product to people who don't understand what they are looking at and simply think more is better. I hate to call out brands but one very well known bird branded company in particular is just laughable to me. Their "data" is utter nonsense aimed at people who think of brakes as one dimensionally as horsepower. Some of the higher end brands don't even bother to publish any data because they just don't want to compete or contribute to the pissing contest that is published friction coefficients. Don't get me wrong, more is better to a certain point but there are so many other factors that go into what makes a great pad compound great for it's intended application. For example how and how much it bleeds off or ramps up torque through the quick temp swing in the braking zones. Or how and how much friction changes with pressure along with temperature, especially at very high temperatures. Or even how consistent a compound remains as it heat cycles and wears down. Brake compounding is a black art and the higher end brands like Endless, PFC, Project Mu, and Ferodo just understand it better and make superior products. We carry or have access to literally every brand of brake pads known to man but we only actively market what we use and have success with.
Anyway, I digress. The data between top tier brands like PMU and Ferodo are much, much more accurate. As I mentioned above the HC+800 will fare a bit better than DS2500 for track use. HC+800 wear very well until they get too got and then the wear rates accelerate exponentially (common with many pad compounds). You've been getting great wear out of the HC+800 on track which leads me to believe you could make the DS2500 work but if I had to guess I'd say you'd burn through them a bit faster than you've been going through HC+800 since they would more than likely be at the very top or slightly above their usable temp range. Endless MX72 do have a higher temp ceiling than the DS2500, in reality I find it's fairly similar to the HC+800 based on the wear rates I've seen on my own car but the price is just the killer with those given how often you go to the track and that there are other options (albeit higher dusting) that are similar in terms of outright performance for so much less.
I do love me some MX72s! That is my preferred pad in my E46 M3 because it's just perfect for the use it sees- a handful of track events each year but it's primarily a street car and I've become a complete brake snob and I enjoy attacking brake zones more with these pads .
The price is undoubtedly the main reason. We've tried so many times to lobby for lower prices on MX72 because they are so damn good and I know more people would switch if we could get them down to something a bit more reasonable. Unfortunately Endless remains firm on their pricing model for these specific pad shapes. In any case they remain the best all around option for pretty much everyone who can stomach the cost of admission.
I would also like to add that pretty much everyone I've ever talked to about them complains about the price at first (understandably so) yet we have the highest brand loyalty with them... I would say at least 95% of the guys who try them come back and happily re-order Endless when they need pads again and I think that speaks volumes. If it wasn't as good as the claims we'd see everyone switching back to something else.
-Matt M.
Let me start with, I am finished looking, unless Ferodo come up with the rear set for our cars, then Ferodo DS2500 front pads and Project Mu HC800+ rear pads will be my combo for as long as I own the F. I would like to thank Matt from SpeedFreaksUSA, just the best place to get your pads from. Thank you!
I am back with my feedback about the front Ferodo DS2500 pads installed. Just as anticipated, very strong pad. Right on par with the Project MU HC+ 800 pads I removed.
IMO these Ferodo DS2500 are best pads for the money if you want top notch performance without any of the race pad non-sense, like noise, grind and dust.
...
I am back with my feedback about the front Ferodo DS2500 pads installed. Just as anticipated, very strong pad. Right on par with the Project MU HC+ 800 pads I removed.
IMO these Ferodo DS2500 are best pads for the money if you want top notch performance without any of the race pad non-sense, like noise, grind and dust.
...
It sounds DS2500/HC+800 could be the new go-to combination for the guys who want to use their cars aggressively on the street but may not take their car to the track as frequently and/or would prefer a little more street civility without making the jump all the way to Endless.
Can the DS2500 perform double duty street and track like the HC800+?
I'm about to get the HC800+ front and rear for double duty (2-3 track days per year) cause I'm getting lazier as I age but if the DS2500 can do the same with less bedding in issues, grinding noise and dust then I'm up for that.
I'm about to get the HC800+ front and rear for double duty (2-3 track days per year) cause I'm getting lazier as I age but if the DS2500 can do the same with less bedding in issues, grinding noise and dust then I'm up for that.
If you're only doing 2-3 events per year you may want to start off with the DS2500 since they will be a bit more street friendly than the HC+800 and that is where the car will be spending the majority of the time. If you know you're going to absolutely punish your brakes on track and don't mind the dust then the HC+800 are not a bad way to start out either.
Thanks for the detailed write up.. I'm interested in an alternative to the HC+800 for two reasons: 1.) Less wear on my front rotors 2.) Less dust during daily driving
The HC+800 seem to be pretty brutal on my front rotors as well.. I'm using the RR Racing two-piece (disks made by Coleman, if I'm not mistaken). However, I'm concerned about the potential delta in operating temps that I see for the Ferodos vs. PMUs. Though, the specs I see on each manufacturer's website may not be an apples to apples comparison.
DS2500: Average friction coefficient of 0.42 over working temperature range of 20°-500°C
HC+800: Applicable Rotor Temperature: 0~800℃
Matt, can you help clarify the operating temps between these pads? As you may recall, I get my pads pretty hot at the track, so I want to make sure I'm not stepping down in the performance category with another pad. I'm also interested in the Endless MX72 as well. I know the Endless pads are very pricey, but they may be worth the extra $$ if I can get the same performance/longevity at the track, without all that dust on the street.. Thanks.
-Mike
The HC+800 seem to be pretty brutal on my front rotors as well.. I'm using the RR Racing two-piece (disks made by Coleman, if I'm not mistaken). However, I'm concerned about the potential delta in operating temps that I see for the Ferodos vs. PMUs. Though, the specs I see on each manufacturer's website may not be an apples to apples comparison.
DS2500: Average friction coefficient of 0.42 over working temperature range of 20°-500°C
HC+800: Applicable Rotor Temperature: 0~800℃
Matt, can you help clarify the operating temps between these pads? As you may recall, I get my pads pretty hot at the track, so I want to make sure I'm not stepping down in the performance category with another pad. I'm also interested in the Endless MX72 as well. I know the Endless pads are very pricey, but they may be worth the extra $$ if I can get the same performance/longevity at the track, without all that dust on the street.. Thanks.
-Mike
Anyway, I digress. The data between top tier brands like PMU and Ferodo are much, much more accurate. As I mentioned above the HC+800 will fare a bit better than DS2500 for track use. HC+800 wear very well until they get too got and then the wear rates accelerate exponentially (common with many pad compounds). You've been getting great wear out of the HC+800 on track which leads me to believe you could make the DS2500 work but if I had to guess I'd say you'd burn through them a bit faster than you've been going through HC+800 since they would more than likely be at the very top or slightly above their usable temp range. Endless MX72 do have a higher temp ceiling than the DS2500, in reality I find it's fairly similar to the HC+800 based on the wear rates I've seen on my own car but the price is just the killer with those given how often you go to the track and that there are other options (albeit higher dusting) that are similar in terms of outright performance for so much less.
Mike^^^^^^^^^I've been running Endless MX72's for over 2 years now and won't run another pad as long as they're made! Ask Matt as Speed Freaks what he prefers, but he stays off the MX72 topic most of the time because nobody likes the price?
It's never made sense to me why some would cheap out on brake pads, but then they'll pony up for Michelin tires (because they are better) but cheap out on brake pads?? To each there own but after you experience a good pad like the MX72's you won't consider anything else. Just like when I purchased my PSS's I will probably stay a Michelin customer for a long time even though you pay more $$ for them, I think the same formula applies to pads?
Just my 2 cents
It's never made sense to me why some would cheap out on brake pads, but then they'll pony up for Michelin tires (because they are better) but cheap out on brake pads?? To each there own but after you experience a good pad like the MX72's you won't consider anything else. Just like when I purchased my PSS's I will probably stay a Michelin customer for a long time even though you pay more $$ for them, I think the same formula applies to pads?
Just my 2 cents
The price is undoubtedly the main reason. We've tried so many times to lobby for lower prices on MX72 because they are so damn good and I know more people would switch if we could get them down to something a bit more reasonable. Unfortunately Endless remains firm on their pricing model for these specific pad shapes. In any case they remain the best all around option for pretty much everyone who can stomach the cost of admission.
I would also like to add that pretty much everyone I've ever talked to about them complains about the price at first (understandably so) yet we have the highest brand loyalty with them... I would say at least 95% of the guys who try them come back and happily re-order Endless when they need pads again and I think that speaks volumes. If it wasn't as good as the claims we'd see everyone switching back to something else.
-Matt M.
The following 2 users liked this post by SpeedFreaksUSA:
mikersoft (10-26-17),
MileHIFcar (10-26-17)