Notes on Timing Belt change -- '95-96
#61
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The verdict
Well, my car has been at the Toyota dealers for 2 days. They just called.
It definately needs a head gasket and they conclude that at least some of the valves are bent. So it needs a valve job and gasket and they estimate it will cost $3,100 to $4,200. I asked if it was the belt change and they just said "could be, we don't know". Logically I have to say it is. I mean it ran fine before and now it doesn't.
Guess I screwed it up. Still not sure what I did wrong??
Now the question is: Do I spend $4,000 on a car that is worth maybe $4,500?
It definately needs a head gasket and they conclude that at least some of the valves are bent. So it needs a valve job and gasket and they estimate it will cost $3,100 to $4,200. I asked if it was the belt change and they just said "could be, we don't know". Logically I have to say it is. I mean it ran fine before and now it doesn't.
Guess I screwed it up. Still not sure what I did wrong??
Now the question is: Do I spend $4,000 on a car that is worth maybe $4,500?
#62
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Oh
Posts: 72
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ouch. I was worried that might be the case from what you had posted. At that point, it would be easier (and cheaper) to take it to an independent mechanic and put a used motor in it.
#63
Lexus Test Driver
iTrader: (1)
Well, my car has been at the Toyota dealers for 2 days. They just called.
It definately needs a head gasket and they conclude that at least some of the valves are bent. So it needs a valve job and gasket and they estimate it will cost $3,100 to $4,200. I asked if it was the belt change and they just said "could be, we don't know". Logically I have to say it is. I mean it ran fine before and now it doesn't.
Guess I screwed it up. Still not sure what I did wrong??
Now the question is: Do I spend $4,000 on a car that is worth maybe $4,500?
It definately needs a head gasket and they conclude that at least some of the valves are bent. So it needs a valve job and gasket and they estimate it will cost $3,100 to $4,200. I asked if it was the belt change and they just said "could be, we don't know". Logically I have to say it is. I mean it ran fine before and now it doesn't.
Guess I screwed it up. Still not sure what I did wrong??
Now the question is: Do I spend $4,000 on a car that is worth maybe $4,500?
#65
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for all the input. Actually I've decided on getting an 05 LS430. I sorta wanted a new(er) car even before all of this.
I'm thinking about donating my LS400 to the local community college auto shop class. Might be a good project for them.
I'm a bit sad about the car. It's been very good to me. I hate to have killed it the way I did. I still don't know where I went wrong but I guess I'll chaulk it up to a learning lesson. The moral of the story is: You CAN screw up a lexus with a timing belt change if you don't know exactly what your doing.
I looked at buying some other cars but hey.............when you've driven a Lexus, it's hard to downgrade
Again, I appreciate all the help.
I'm thinking about donating my LS400 to the local community college auto shop class. Might be a good project for them.
I'm a bit sad about the car. It's been very good to me. I hate to have killed it the way I did. I still don't know where I went wrong but I guess I'll chaulk it up to a learning lesson. The moral of the story is: You CAN screw up a lexus with a timing belt change if you don't know exactly what your doing.
I looked at buying some other cars but hey.............when you've driven a Lexus, it's hard to downgrade
Again, I appreciate all the help.
#67
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Picking up the LS430 today but I'm still thinking about the LS400 that is lying dead at the dealer. I went there today to settle up ($110.00) and just get the car towed away. I plan to take it to an indy mechanic for a second opinion.
The write up from the dealer just said the "head gasket is blown". I asked him how they checked this and he said they removed the intake manifold.
Obviously, this is deeper into auto mechanics than I usually go so my question is: Is this possible?
I mean on a car with absolutely no problems before, no smoking, no apparant mixing of oil/coolant (at least from what I could see) and no loss of power, misfire, ect......
The car ran fine the day before I removed the timing belt. But backtracking, first the heat quit working and I told myself I'd get to it that weekend. On Friday of that week, I noticed the car began to overheat. I noticed this as I pulled into my driveway and noticed coolant dripping from the overflow tank.
So damn..........now that I think about, was I stupid enough to drive while the temp was in the RED ZONE. If so, I didn't notice it. Did it get hot enought to blow the gasket? THAT is my real question.
Because after the belt was on, it ran rough but it did not overheat. Maybe I didn't run it long enough.
Okay, I guess I was just thinking outloud. So maybe the timing belt issue was a side issue. Maybe the blown gasket was the problem the whole time.
Hmmmm............Live and Learn. Damn expensive lesson though. I'll let you guys know what the good independent mechanic says.
The write up from the dealer just said the "head gasket is blown". I asked him how they checked this and he said they removed the intake manifold.
Obviously, this is deeper into auto mechanics than I usually go so my question is: Is this possible?
I mean on a car with absolutely no problems before, no smoking, no apparant mixing of oil/coolant (at least from what I could see) and no loss of power, misfire, ect......
The car ran fine the day before I removed the timing belt. But backtracking, first the heat quit working and I told myself I'd get to it that weekend. On Friday of that week, I noticed the car began to overheat. I noticed this as I pulled into my driveway and noticed coolant dripping from the overflow tank.
So damn..........now that I think about, was I stupid enough to drive while the temp was in the RED ZONE. If so, I didn't notice it. Did it get hot enought to blow the gasket? THAT is my real question.
Because after the belt was on, it ran rough but it did not overheat. Maybe I didn't run it long enough.
Okay, I guess I was just thinking outloud. So maybe the timing belt issue was a side issue. Maybe the blown gasket was the problem the whole time.
Hmmmm............Live and Learn. Damn expensive lesson though. I'll let you guys know what the good independent mechanic says.
#68
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Oh
Posts: 72
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That sure sounds strange... why would they remove your intake manifold if you brought it in for timing belt issues? And wouldn't just the removal of the intake manifold cost more than $110 at dealer shop rates?
#69
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BTW, the LS430 I picked up yesterday is great. I didn't really realize how much they've changed since '96. Lots of gadgets (probably more to break eventually though).
Still trying to get the 400 to the indy mechanic. He doesn't seem too anxious to return my call.
Last edited by tomeyeman; 05-11-10 at 02:56 PM.
#70
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: NC
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Got the LS400 at a machine shop to check on the price of a rebuild vs. a used engine. The indy mechanic basically said he doesn't recommened a top end-only rebuild and I'd be better off doing the whole thing.
Mechanics apparantly work on their own time frame, different from the rest of the world, so maybe I'll find something out while it's still 2010.
Mechanics apparantly work on their own time frame, different from the rest of the world, so maybe I'll find something out while it's still 2010.
#73