What Octane Gasoline For sc430? Premium fuel required? (Merged threads)
#196
This thread has taken a nasty turn. Rather unusual for this forum.
I think we can all agree, for the best performance, use premium. That's exactly what Lexus says.
I think we can also all agree that one tank of regular is not going to cause damage. It's not like filling it up with diesel where one tank will be a no go situation.
I think the OP's question is: "If I don't care about the best performance and I'm willing to give up the fastest 0-60 time, will any actual damage be caused by routinely using regular."
In this respect it's not a matter of "affording" the gas such that you should "rethink what you drive." It's not a matter of "$6 or 7 bucks making that much of a difference." The question is: am I just throwing that money away for nothing if I don't care about the best performance.
I think we can all agree, for the best performance, use premium. That's exactly what Lexus says.
I think we can also all agree that one tank of regular is not going to cause damage. It's not like filling it up with diesel where one tank will be a no go situation.
I think the OP's question is: "If I don't care about the best performance and I'm willing to give up the fastest 0-60 time, will any actual damage be caused by routinely using regular."
In this respect it's not a matter of "affording" the gas such that you should "rethink what you drive." It's not a matter of "$6 or 7 bucks making that much of a difference." The question is: am I just throwing that money away for nothing if I don't care about the best performance.
I guess now would be a good time to say, this is the most helpful forum I have ever belonged too and would respectfully like to ask anyone who is new, not to be rude to each other. This forum is not like that, please don’t change the best.
with that said, I am not perfect and have bad days too, when I did, other members reminded me and I went back and deleted or rewrote my post.
The following 3 users liked this post by Bgw70:
#198
It didn't, but I noticed I got 2 miles less per gallon and the car wasn't as quick off the line.
Back then 91 was only 10 cents more a gallon.
I did the math in my head. If I was getting 26 miles a gallon for $3.00 or 24 miles for 2.90 it was cheaper, per mile, for me to run Premium.
Full disclosure, that was like 15 years ago, so I don't remember the actual miles and gas prices. But I do remember the math worked out.
#199
I would agree with that. I used to have a Volvo C70 convertible and a 25 mile commute. I figured that burning 87 octane for twenty miles on Cruise Control wouldn't hurt anything.
It didn't, but I noticed I got 2 miles less per gallon and the car wasn't as quick off the line.
Back then 91 was only 10 cents more a gallon.
I did the math in my head. If I was getting 26 miles a gallon for $3.00 or 24 miles for 2.90 it was cheaper, per mile, for me to run Premium.
Full disclosure, that was like 15 years ago, so I don't remember the actual miles and gas prices. But I do remember the math worked out.
It didn't, but I noticed I got 2 miles less per gallon and the car wasn't as quick off the line.
Back then 91 was only 10 cents more a gallon.
I did the math in my head. If I was getting 26 miles a gallon for $3.00 or 24 miles for 2.90 it was cheaper, per mile, for me to run Premium.
Full disclosure, that was like 15 years ago, so I don't remember the actual miles and gas prices. But I do remember the math worked out.
they sure are taking us to the cleaners these days.
also, don’t ya like the way, when oil goes up, the pump price goes up the same day but when it goes down, it takes days for the pump price to come down! LoL
Last edited by Bgw70; 07-19-18 at 01:44 PM.
#200
Also, all the gas stations raise the price the same amount at the same time, but there's no collusion. That would be wrong.
#201
#202
I would agree with that. I used to have a Volvo C70 convertible and a 25 mile commute. I figured that burning 87 octane for twenty miles on Cruise Control wouldn't hurt anything.
It didn't, but I noticed I got 2 miles less per gallon and the car wasn't as quick off the line.
Back then 91 was only 10 cents more a gallon.
I did the math in my head. If I was getting 26 miles a gallon for $3.00 or 24 miles for 2.90 it was cheaper, per mile, for me to run Premium.
Full disclosure, that was like 15 years ago, so I don't remember the actual miles and gas prices. But I do remember the math worked out.
It didn't, but I noticed I got 2 miles less per gallon and the car wasn't as quick off the line.
Back then 91 was only 10 cents more a gallon.
I did the math in my head. If I was getting 26 miles a gallon for $3.00 or 24 miles for 2.90 it was cheaper, per mile, for me to run Premium.
Full disclosure, that was like 15 years ago, so I don't remember the actual miles and gas prices. But I do remember the math worked out.
To be clear the only difference between higher octane gas and regular octane is the higher octane gas has a higher pressure combustion point. The greater the compression, the higher the temperature within the combustion chamber. And the higher the temperature, the greater the thermal efficiency and power produced. There are no other differences. Premium does not have more energy, it is not cleaner, it does not burn better...there are no other differences besides a higher pressure/temp combustion for premium despite the years of marketing hype and BS most adults have been exposed to by gas retailers.
My individual experience having tested regular versus premium tanks of fuel over the course of multiple road trips (1-1.5 k trips) is that on the LS430 there is no change in mpg.. I assume there would be less power at some rpm range using regular if the ECU has set the timing slightly back to accommodate using regular, but I personally did not feel it (but I would be unlikely to feel a power loss as I drive like an old geezer 95% of the time). I assume the SC430 engine which is identical in most ways, would produce same or similar results. Most of my trips were on a very flat interstate cruising at pretty constant 70-75 mph with the engine is loafing along. Given the ECU is constantly monitoring engine sensors (MAF, temps, O2, etc.) and is making changes based on those readings, there actually may not be a change in mpg or power under easy driving conditions that do not stress the motor.
Running the same test on a more difficult roads, and/or at higher speeds, or higher ambient temps, or more aggressive driving style might produce much different results.
Last edited by Jabberwock; 07-19-18 at 08:04 PM.
#205
There is also evidence that prolonged use of regular or 87 can lead to premature failure of the catalytic converter system. This is due a less than ideal combustion within the engine and fuel gets into the cats. The car will run on low octane but it is not designed / programed to use this fuel. By using 87 you are forcing the car to pull timing to avoid knocking. Best to use 91 and above and use a fuel system cleaner often. Marvel Mystey Oil (MMO) works great and is much cheaped than other products. One bottle will treat 4 - 5 tanks of fuel for $4. Also fantastic to help clean the carbon out of the engine. Add about 1/2 a bottle with your oil change. I use religiously in all my vehicles. Not some miracle product. Just does what it's supposed to. Cleans carbon and uses friction modifiers to help protect against cold start wear.
Last edited by Lavrishevo; 06-14-20 at 07:10 AM.
The following users liked this post:
CCC-TT (06-15-20)
#206
There is also evidence that prolonged use of regular or 87 can lead to premature failure of the catalytic converter system. This is due a less than ideal combustion within the engine and fuel gets into the cats. The car will run on low octane but it is not designed / programed to use this fuel. By using 87 you are forcing the car to pull timing to avoid knocking. Best to use 91 and above and use a fuel system cleaner often. Marvel Mystey Oil (MMO) works great and is much cheaped than other products. One bottle will treat 4 - 5 tanks of fuel for $4. Also fantastic to help clean the carbon out of the engine. Add about 1/2 a bottle with your oil change. I use religiously in all my vehicles. Not some miracle product. Just does what it's supposed to. Cleans carbon and uses friction modifiers to help protect against cold start wear.
#207
I will give you a very easy example you can try yourself. If running 87 for a few tanks and you open her up, WOT, you will smell more of a rotten egg smell vs premium fuel. This is true to many cars that prefer premium fuel. That smell is fuel entering the exhaust system without being burned. This will eventually ruin catalytic converters.
#208
I will give you a very easy example you can try yourself. If running 87 for a few tanks and you open her up, WOT, you will smell more of a rotten egg smell vs premium fuel. This is true to many cars that prefer premium fuel. That smell is fuel entering the exhaust system without being burned. This will eventually ruin catalytic converters.
#209
Funny I just gave my 430 her first fill up Friday since owning her. I got her back from the detailer and stopped at BJ's and put in premium, I don't recall the number. Then put a few bucks in my 400 today on my way into work. I was running late but put 91 in, will fill up with 91 on my way home.
#210
Last edited by Lavrishevo; 06-15-20 at 08:20 AM.
The following users liked this post:
CCC-TT (06-15-20)